action for possession if the money damages sought exceed $10,000 (which is often the
case for a commercial lease).
Under those circumstances, a landlord will file a Chapter 42 summary ejectment
action seeking only possession and court costs, and then bring a second, separate action
for money damages against the tenant in either district court (if the damages run from
$10,001 to $25,000) or superior court (if the damages exceed $25,000). (Per N.C.G.S. §
7A-243, as amended in 2013 by Session Law 2013-159, actions seeking between $10,001
and $25,000 in damages and filed from August 1, 2013 through June 30, 2015 can be
filed at the plaintiff’s election in either district court or superior court.) A separate action
is clearly authorized by Chapter 42 for money owed by the tenant to the landlord if
possession only (plus court costs) is sought in the summary ejectment action. See
N.C.G.S. § 42-28 (If landlord “omits to make such a claim [for money damages], he shall
not be prejudiced thereby in any other action for their recovery.”) However, if any
money damages are sought in the summary ejectment action, the plaintiff is precluded
from seeking additional money damages from the tenant in a separate (bifurcated) action,
because res judicata principles require that all money damages must be recovered in a
single action. See Chrisalis Properties, Inc. v. Separate Quarters, Inc., 101 N.C. App. 81
(1990), disc. review denied, 328 N.C. 570 (1991)(not possible for landlord to split its
money damages into two causes of action such that some of the money damages are
sought in one action and the remainder are sought in a different action).
Issues relating to major bifurcated collections actions brought against tenants
(either in or out of possession) in district or superior court to recover money owed are
beyond the scope of this manuscript. Such actions are typically based on breach of