There are four critical elements is successful land bank initiatives:
1. Connect the Land Bank to the tax collection and foreclosure system. Tax
collection is the principal interaction with abandoned properties –as owners typically do
not pay taxes on abandoned property. The effective use of the governments’ superior
tax lien can be the primary mechanism of acquisition of the properties. Further,
connecting the economics of tax collection to the management and disposition of
properties coming through the process is a critical element. Most tax systems privatize
profits through penalties and interest earned by tax lien investors, or from equity derived
from more valuable properties that are foreclosed. The land bank model captures that
revenue stream and utilizes those financial resources to manage the properties held by
the land bank. In both scenarios, the property would be lost to the owner – this
‘improved’ system simply places that process and the earnings derived from the
collection process under the control of the community, not out-of-state speculators. It is
imperative that any such public system include a strong foreclosure prevention effort.
2. Scale the land bank at the metropolitan level, or around the most diverse real
estate market possible. Land banks are most effective when they are not relegated to
ownership of only the worst of the foreclosed or abandoned properties. A common
fallacy of tax foreclosure – or property abandonment – is that it is all “junk” property.
While most of the properties titled to land banks would meet that definition, it is the case
that a small percentage of tax-foreclosed properties have some market value –
occasionally significant value. By scaling the land bank around a diverse market, the
possibility is increased that more valuable properties conveyed to private ownership
through a land bank will generate revenues to be used in managing and improving the
most difficult properties. This source of internal subsidy is founded on the notion that a
land bank is better positioned than a public auction to convert valuable properties to
productive use, and can utilize the earnings from land sales to rehabilitate, clean, board,
or even bulldoze other properties in worse condition. The Genesee County Land Bank
generates between $500,000 and $1 million per year in land sales, money which not
only recovers the uncollected taxes on those properties, but also funds a robust property
maintenance program.
3. Ensure a Land Bank is policy driven – and transparent in policies and
transactions. The public –for good reason – is often suspicious of any government role
in the real estate market. In the case of these properties, of course, the government
already owns the property as a result of tax foreclosure. Still, it is critical that the
operation of a land bank be fair and predictable. To build public confidence in a Land
Bank, the adoption of well considered policies and priorities that govern to whom –and
for what purpose – properties are sold or transferred. Terms and pricing policy must be
clear and uniform, as well.
Page | 3