!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
"#$%&'!(#)%*#+!!
#)!*,-!#../!&,/+*-+!
012314516!7899!
Center for Migrant Advocacy (CMA)
Migrants Rights Policy Monitor
September 2011
CMA's Migrants Rights Policy Monitor is
supported by the Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES)
!"
"#$%&'!(#)%*#+!!
#)!*,-!#../!&,/+*-+!
!
&1:316!;<6!(=>6?:3!/@A<B?BC!!
012314516!7899!
!
!
%)*+#DE&*%#)!!
*F=G!@<BH41:3!=G!?:!1;;<63!3<!4<:=3<6I!=:!3164G!<;!2<J=BCI!3F1!26<2<G1@!&F?6316!<;!
3F1! #A16G1?G! .<6K16G! .1J;?61! /@4=:=G36?3=<:! L#../MN! &61?31@! 5C! ?! 261G=@1:3=?J!
J13316!<;!=:G36HB3=<:!O=3F!3F1!=:31:3!<;!?GG=G3=:>!3F1!<A16G1?G!P=J=2=:<!O<6K16G!L#P.GM!
=:!3164G!<;!O1J;?61!?:@!36?=:=:>!;<6!4<61!3F?:!3F611!@1B?@1G!:<OI!#../!F?G!:<O!
>6<O:!=:3<!?:!?>1:BC!O=3F!5=JJ=<:!21G<!Q!O<63F!<;!;H:@!2<<J1@!;6<4!4=JJ=<:G!<;!#P.G!
OF<!F?A1!3<=J1@!<A16G1?GN!.F1:!>J<GG1@Q<A16I!3F161!G114G!3<!51!:<!26<5J14I!5H3!
OF1:! <:1! G3?631@! 3<! ?GK1@! OFC! 3F1! #../! ;H:@! B<JJ1B31@! ;6<4! 3F1! #P.G! =G!
B<:36<JJ1@! 5C! 3F1! ><A16:41:3! ?:@! 3F?3! 3F1! 414516G! 3F14G1JA1G! F?A1! @=;;=BHJ3C!
?BB1GG=:>!=3I!3F1:!3F1!26<5J14!=G!61?J!?:@!:11@G!H6>1:3!?B3=<:N!
%:BJH@1@!=:!3F=G!@<BH41:3!=G!?!B<JJ1B31@!612JC!<;!#P.G!;6<4!?!GH6A1C!B<:@HB31@!<:!
3F1!1R216=1:B1G!<;!#P.G!=:!?BB1GG=:>!O1J;?61!?:@!<3F16!G16A=B1G!;6<4!3F1!#../N!
/JG<!=:BJH@1@!?61!G?J=1:3!2<=:3G!;6<4!3F1!26<2<G1@!#../!&F?6316I!=:!<6@16!3<!G3?63!
3F1!:1B1GG?6C!?:@!<A16@H1!@15?31!<:!3F1!4?3316N!#../!G3?:@G!;<6!G<413F=:>!A16C!
=42<63?:3I!?:@!=3!=G!B6=3=B?J!3F?3!&<:>61GG!@1;=:1G!3F1!:?3H61!<;!#../I!<:B1!?:@!;<6!
?JJI! G<! 3F?3! =3! B?:! 61G2<:G=5JC! ;HJ;=JJ! =3G! 4?:@?31! 3<! J<<K! ?;316! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;! 3F1!
#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!
!
(?:C! <;! 3F1G1! SH1G3=<:G! ?61! =:31661J?31@! ?:@! B<::1B31@I! G<! 3F?3! F<O! <:1! =G!
?:GO161@!?;;1B3G!?JJ!3F1!<3F16GN!P<6!1R?42J1I!=;!#../!=G!?:!T=:GH6?:B1!GBF141IT!=3!
4?K1G!G1:G1!;<6!=3!3<!51!?!T414516GF=2!<6>?:=U?3=<:NT!VH3!?J316:?3=A1JCI!=;!#../!=G!
?! 26<31B3=<:! ?>1:BCI! =3! 4HG3! 51! ;<6! ?JJ! #P.GI! 61>?6@J1GG! <;! G3?3HGN!
!
#;! B<H6G1I! <:B1! #../WG! 6<J1! =G! @1;=:1@I! 3F1! 4<G3! =42<63?:3! G312! 614?=:GX! 3<!
1:GH61! 3F?3! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;! 1A16C! #P.! =G! ?@1SH?31JC! 26<31B31@! 5C! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1!
><A16:41:3N! %;! #../I! =:! =3G! ;=:?J! ;<64?3=<:I! 1RBJH@1G! ?:C! #P.GI! &<:>61GG! 4HG3!
1G3?5J=GF!?!41BF?:=G4!3<!26<31B3!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!3F<G1!#P.GN!%;!?:C!B6=3=B?J!O1J;?61!
:11@G!?61!J1;3!H:?:GO161@I!&<:>61GG!4HG3!;=:@!?!O?C!3<!B<A16!3F<G1!:11@GN!
V+%-P!V/&YZ+#E)D!
,?A=:>!?:!<A163!2<J=BC!<;!1R2<63=:>!=3G!FH4?:!B?2=3?J!;<6!4<61!3F?:!3F611!@1B?@1GI!
3F1! "F=J=22=:1! ><A16:41:3! F?G! B61?31@! =:G3=3H3=<:G! 3F?3! 4?:?>1! ?J4<G3! 1A16C!
DVSHFW RI PLJUDWLRQ 7KHVH LQVWLWXWLRQV· IXQFWLRQV DQG VHUYLFHV UDQJH IURP
@12J<C41:3I!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!3F1!O<6K16!?:@!F=G[F16!;?4=JC!OF=J1!O<6K=:>!<A16G1?GI!
3<! F=G[F16! 1A1:3H?J! 613H6:! ?:@! 61=:31>6?3=<:N! ! *FHGI! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1G! F?G! 511:!
B<:G=@161@! >J<5?JJC! ?G! ?! 4<@1J! ;<6! 4?:?>=:>! =3G! B<:3=:H=:>! =:;JHR! <;! <A16G1?G!
O<6K16GN!
#"
"H5J=B! 2<J=BC! <:! <A16G1?G! J?5<6! 142J<C41:3! ;<64?JJC! G3?631@! =:! 9\]^! OF1:!
"61G=@1:3! P16@=:?:@! (?6B<G! =GGH1@! ?! 261G=@1:3=?J! @1B611! B61?3=:>! 3F611!
><A16:41:3! =:G3=3H3=<:G! O=3F=:! 3F1! (=:=G36C! <;! $?5<6! 3<! ;?B=J=3?31! 3F1! 1R2<63! <;!
O<6K16GX! ! 3F1! #A16G1?G! -42J<C41:3! D1A1J<241:3! V<?6@! L#-DVMI! 3F1! VH61?H! <;!
-42J<C41:3! 016A=B1G! LV-0MI! ?:@! 3F1! )?3=<:?J! 01?41:! V<?6@!L)0VMN! /G! <A16G1?G!
142J<C41:3!B<:3=:H1!3<!=:B61?G1!G=>:=;=B?:3JCI!3F1!"F=J=22=:1!><A16:41:3!O?G!:<3!
?5J1! 3<! 4?:?>1! 3F1! H2GH6>1! =:! @14?:@! ;<6! 61B6H=3=:>! ?:@! @12J<C=:>! <A16G1?G!
O<6K16GN!!!
/!9\]]! .F=31! "?216!5C!3F1! (=:=G36C! L:<O! D12?6341:3M!<;!$?5<6!?:@! -42J<C41:3!
61B<441:@1@!3F?3! 3F1!><A16:41:3! ;<BHG!<:! 26<31B3=:>!?:@! 26<4<3=:>!3F1! 6=>F3G!
?:@!O1J;?61!<;!3F1!6=>F3G!<;!#A16G1?G!P=J=2=:<!.<6K16G!6?3F16!3F?:!;<BHG!G<J1JC!<:!
61B6H=3=:>!?:@!2J?B=:>!3F14N!
#../!/*!/!Z$/)&-!
/!.1J;?61!?:@!*6?=:=:>!PH:@!;<6!#A16G1?G!.<6K16G!L.*P#.M!O?G!B61?31@!H:@16!3F1!
D#$-! =:! 9\]]! 3F6<H>F! $13316! <;! %:G36HB3=<:! L$#%M! )<N! _`]N! $#%! _`]! 26<A=@1G! ;<6!
G<B=?J! ?:@! O1J;?61! G16A=B1GI! OF=BF! =:BJH@1G! =:GH6?:B1! B<A16?>1I! 2J?B141:3!
?GG=G3?:B1!?:@!614=33?:B1!G16A=B1GI!?4<:>!<3F16GI!3<!P=J=2=:<!4=>6?:3!O<6K16GN!*F1!
$#%! J=K1O=G1I! 26<A=@1G! ;<6! GK=JJG! 36?=:=:>! ?:@! B?6116! @1A1J<241:3! G16A=B1G! ;<6! 3F1!
@12?63=:>! O<6K16GN! *F1! .*P#.! O?G! ;H:@1@! 3F6<H>F! 1?6:=:>G! ?:@! O1J;?61! ;H:@!
B<JJ1B3=<:G! ;6<4! 3F1! #-DVI! 3F1! V-0I! 3F1! )0V! ?:@! <3F16! @<:?3=<:G! ?:@!
B<:36=5H3=<:GN!
%:!9\a8I!$#%!_`]!O?G!;<64?J=U1@!5C!3F1!=GGH?:B1!<;!"D!9b^\I!B61?3=:>!3F1!.1J;?61!
PH:@!;<6!#A16G1?G!.<6K16G!L.1J;H:@MN!*F1!.1J;H:@!O?G!4?:@?31@!3<!26<A=@1!G<B=?J!
?:@! O1J;?61! G16A=B1G! 3<! P=J=2=:<! 4=>6?:3! O<6K16GI! =:BJH@=:>! =:GH6?:B1! B<A16?>1I!
J1>?J! ?GG=G3?:B1I! 2J?B141:3! ?GG=G3?:B1!?:@! 614=33?:B1! G16A=B1GN! /JJ! B<:36=5H3=<:G!
3<!3F1!.*P#.!O161!36?:G;1661@!3<!3F1!.1J;H:@N!
%:! 9\a9I! "D! 9a8\! O?G! =GGH1@! ?41:@=:>! B163?=:! 26<A=G=<:G! <;! "D! 9b^\N!
/41:@41:3G! =:BJH@1! 1R2?:@=:>! 3F1! :H4516! <;! .1J;H:@! V<?6@! <;! *6HG311G! ;6<4!
G1A1:! L]M! 3<! 1J1A1:! L99Mc! 3F1! ?@4=:=G36?3=<:! <;! 3F1! .1J;H:@! 5C! 3F1! V<?6@! <;!
*6HG311G! 3F6<H>F! ?! 01B613?6=?3c! ?:@! 3F1! HG1! <;! ><A16:41:3! 5?:KG! ?G! @12<G=3<6C!
5?:KG!;<6!3F1!.1J;H:@N!
.=3F!3F1!61Q<6>?:=U?3=<:!<;!3F1!D#$-!5C!-#!97b!=:!9\a]I!3F1!.1J;H:@!O?G!61:?41@!
#A16G1?G! .<6K16G! .1J;?61! /@4=:=G36?3=<:! L#../MN! ! -R1BH3=A1! #6@16! L-#M! 9\_I!
=GGH1@! <:! /H>HG3! 9`I! 9\\^I! 1R2?:@1@! 3F1! GB<21! <;! #../I! 26<A=@=:>! ;<6!
B<42HJG<6C! (1@=B?61! B<A16?>1! 3<! ?JJ! #P.G! ?:@! 3F1=6! @121:@1:3GI! 1RB123! 3F<G1!
O=3F!1R=G3=:>!B<A16?>1!O=3F!3F1!Z<A16:41:3! 016A=B1!%:GH6?:B1!0CG314!LZ0%0M!?:@!
3F1!0<B=?J!01BH6=3C!0CG314!L000M!A<JH:3?6C!414516GF=2!26<>6?4N!
#:! 012314516! 9\I! 788`I! 3F1! #../! V<?6@! <;! *6HG311G! 26<4HJ>?31@! V<?6@!
+1G<JH3=<:! )<N! `a! L#4:=5HG! "<J=B=1GMI! 26<A=@=:>! 3F1! >H=@1J=:1G! <:! 4?3316G!
B<:B16:=:>! #../! 414516GF=2! ?:@! B<A16?>1I! B<JJ1B3=<:! <;! B<:36=5H3=<:GI!
?A?=J41:3! <;! 51:1;=3GI! ?:@! 3F1! 2<J=B=1G! <:! ;H:@! 4?:?>141:3I! 26<>6?4G! ?:@!
G16A=B1GI!?@4=:=G36?3=<:!I!?:@!B<62<6?31!><A16:?:B1N!
$"
2::$·V REM1B3=A1G! =:BJH@1! 3F1! ;<JJ<O=:>X! 3F1! 26<31B3=<:! <;! 3F1! =:3161G3! ?:@!
26<4<3=<:! <;! 3F1!O1J;?61! <;! #P.Gc! =42J141:3?3=<:! <;!3F1! $?5<6!&<@1! 3F?3! O<HJ@!
26<4<31!3F1!O1JJQ51=:>!<;!#P.Gc!26<A=G=<:!<;!G<B=?J!?:@!O1J;?61!G16A=B1G!3<!#P.Gc!
1;;=B=1:3!B<JJ1B3=<:!?:@!GHG3?=:?5=J=3C!<;!3F1!;H:@c!1:F?:B141:3!<;!3F1!O1JJQ51=:>!<;!
#P.0! 3F6<H>F! G3H@=1G! ?:@! 61G1?6BFc! ?:@! @1A1J<241:3! ?:@! ;=:?:B=:>! <;! G21B=;=B!
26<d1B3G!3<!26<4<31!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!#P.GN!
7KH SDVVDJH RI 5$  RU WKH ´0LJUDQW :RUNHUV DQG 2YHUVHDV )LOLSLQRV $FW RI
µ!?:@!+/!98877!OF=BF!?41:@1@!+/!a8^7!3<!;H63F16!=426<A1!3F1!G3?:@?6@G!<;!
26<31B3=<:! ?:@! 26<4<3=<:! <;! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;! 4=>6?:3! O<6K16G! ?:@! 3F1=6! ;?4=J=1GI!
BJ?6=;=1@!?:@!1:F?:B1@!3F1!4?:@?31!<;!#../!3<!=:BJH@1X!
9N +12?36=?3=<:!<;! O<6K16G! =:! B?G1G!<;!O?6I! 12=@14=BI! :?3H6?J!<6!4?:Q4?@1!
@=G?G316! <6! B?J?4=3=1GI! ?:@! <3F16! G=4=J?6! 1A1:3G! O=3F<H3! 261dH@=B1! 3<!
61=45H6G141:3! 5C! 3F1! 142J<C16! <6! 3F1! 61B6H=341:3! ?>1:BCN! %:! B?G1G!
OF161!3F1!142J<C16!<6!3F1!61B6H=341:3!?>1:BC!B?::<3!51!=@1:3=;=1@!#../!
GF?JJ! 51?6! ?JJ! B<G3G! <;! 612?36=?3=<:N! /:! -416>1:BC! +12?36=?3=<:! PH:@! =G!
B61?31@! H:@16! 3F1! ?@4=:=G36?3=<:I! B<:36<J! ?:@! GH216A=G=<:! <;! #../! ;<6!
3F=G! 2H62<G1N! #../!GF?JJ! ?JG<!2?C! ;<6! 3F1!612?36=?3=<:Q61J?31@!1R21:G1G!
GHBF!?G!;=:1G!<6!21:?J3=1GN!
!
7N -G3?5J=GF41:3! <;! ?! +12J?B141:3! ?:@! (<:=3<6=:>! &1:316! ;<6! 613H6:=:>!
4=>6?:3!O<6K16GI!OF161=:!#../I!3<>13F16!O=3F!3F1!D#$-!?:@!3F1!"#-/I!
?61!3?GK1@!3<!;<64HJ?31!?!26<>6?4!3F?3!O=JJ!4<3=A?31! 4=>6?:3!O<6K16G!3<!
2J?:! ;<6! 26<@HB3=A1! <23=<:GI!GHBF! ?G!1:36C! =:3<! F=>FJC! 31BF:=B?J!d<5G! ?:@!
=:A1G341:3!<;!G?A=:>GI!?4<:>!<3F16GN!
!
`N &61?3=<:! <;! ?! (=>6?:3! .<6K16G! $<?:! ZH?6?:311! PH:@! 3<! 261A1:3! =JJ1>?J!
61B6H=316G!;6<4!3?K=:>!?@A?:3?>1!<;!O<6K16G!G11K=:>!142J<C41:3!?56<?@N!
*F1! #../I! =:! B<<6@=:?3=<:! O=3F! ><A16:41:3! ;=:?:B=?J! =:G3=3H3=<:GI! =G!
4?:@?31@! 3<! =:G3=3H31! ;=:?:B=?J! GBF141G! 1R2?:@=:>! 3F1! >6?:3! <;! 261Q
@12?63H61!?:@!;?4=JC!?GG=G3?:B1!J<?:GN!
!
^N P<64HJ?3=<:!?:@!=42J141:3?3=<:!<;!26<>6?4G!;<6!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1G!
OF=J1! 3F1C! ?61! ?56<?@! ?:@! H2<:! 3F1=6! 613H6:N! ! %3! GF?JJ! ?JG<! 1:GH61! 3F1!
?O?61:1GG! 5C! 3F1! #P.G!?:@!3F1=6! ;?4=J=1G!<;! 3F1G1!26<>6?4G!?:@! <3F16!
61J?31@!><A16:41:3?J!26<>6?4GN!
7KH2::$·V%RDUGRI7UXVWHHVLVDWULSDUWLWHERG\ZLWKWKH'2/(6HFUHWDU\DVFKDLU
?:@! 97! 414516G! 61261G1:3=:>! ><A16:41:3I! 4?:?>141:3I! ?:@! #P.GN! *F1!
"61G=@1:3! <;! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1G! ?22<=:3G! ?JJ! 5<?6@! 414516GN! ! *F1! 5<?6@! =G! 56<?@JC!
61261G1:3?3=A1! <;! ?! B6<GGQG1B3=<:! <;! ><A16:41:3! ?>1:B=1GI! =:BJH@=:>! 3F1!
D12?6341:3G!<;!P<61=>:!/;;?=6GI!P=:?:B1I!?:@!VH@>13N!#P.G!?61!?JJ<331@!G1?Q5?G1@I!
J?:@QEDVHGDQGZRPHQ·VVHFWRUUHSUHVHQWDWLYHV!
*F1! 5<?6@! 2J?:G! ?:@! =42J141:3G! 2<J=B=1G! ?:@! 26<>6?4GI! B6?;3G! 3F1! 6HJ1G! ?:@!
61>HJ?3=<:GI! <A16G11G! ;H:@! G<H6B1GI! ?:@! B61?31G! C1?6JC! ?226<26=?3=<:G! ;<6! 3F1!
6HFUHWDULDW 2::$·V DGPLQLVWUDWLYH DUP 8QOLNH RWKHU 3KLOLSSLQH JRYHUQPHQW
?>1:B=1G!3F?3!?@4=:=G316!36HG3!;H:@GI!#../!F?G!:<!BF?6316N!*F=G!G13H2!?JJ<OG!;<6!
4<61!;J1R=5=J=3C!5H3! 4?C! ?JG<!?JJ<O!3F1! 5<?6@! 3<!1R16B=G1! 5J?:K13!?:@!H:61>HJ?31@!
%"
DXWKRULW\$VDSHUPDQHQWJRYHUQPHQWDJHQF\FKDQJHVWR2::$·VRSHUDWLRQVFDQ
<:JC!51!4?@1!3F6<H>F!J1>=GJ?3=<:N!
#../!=G!?@4=:=G3161@!5C!3F1!V<?6@!<;!*6HG311G!3F6<H>F!3F1!01B613?6=?3!F1?@1@!5C!
3F1! /@4=:=G36?3<6! ?G! 3F1! &F=1;! -R1BH3=A1! #;;=B16! ?:@! ?GG=G31@! 5C! 3O<! D12H3C!
/@4=:=G36?3<6GN!
*F1!01B613?6=?3I!F1?@1@!5C!?:!?@4=:=G36?3<6I!4?:?>1G!@?CQ3<Q@?C!<216?3=<:G!=:!3F1!
"F=J=22=:1G! ?:@! ?56<?@N! /J3F<H>F! =3G! 4?=:! <;;=B1! =G! =:! (?:=J?I! #../! F?G! 9]!
61>=<:?J! <;;=B1G! O=3F=:! 3F1! B<H:36C! ?:@! _! G?31JJ=31! <;;=B1G! =:! 3F1! )?3=<:?J! &?2=3?J!
+1>=<:I! +1>=<:G! 9I! `I! _! ?:@! /+((! OF161! 3F161! ?61! J?6>1! :H4516G! <;! 4=>6?:3!
O<6K16GN!*F1!O1J;?61!<;;=B16G!?56<?@!O<6K!=:!3F1!"F=J=22=:1!#A16G1?G!$?5<6!#;;=B16G!
L"#$#GM!3<>13F16!O=3F!3F1!J?5<6!?33?BFeG!?:@!3F1!?45?GG?@<6G!<6!B<:GHJGQ>1:16?J!
3<! ?GG=G3! P=J=2=:<! 4=>6?:3! O<6K16GN! ! *F1! "#$#G! ?61!HGH?JJC! ?33?BF1@! 3<! "F=J=22=:1!
145?GG=1G!?:@!B<:GHJ?31GN!%:@11@I!3F1!><A16:41:3!B<:G=@16G!#../!G3?;;!?56<?@!
3<!51!2?63!<;!=3G!H:=;=1@!31?4!=:!3F?3!B<H:36C!H:@16!3F1!#:1!&<H:36CQ*1?4!/226<?BFI!
O=3F!3F1!?45?GG?@<6!?G!3F1!F1?@!<;!3F1!31?4N!!
(14516GF=2!=:!#../I!H2<:!B<:36=5H3=<:!<;!E0f7_N88I!=G!4?:@?3<6C!;<6!4=>6?:3G!
><=:>!?56<?@!3F6<H>F!<;;=B=?J!BF?::1JG!5C!1:6<JJ41:3!H2<:!26<B1GG=:>!<;!?!B<:36?B3!
?3!"#-/!<6!5C!A<JH:3?6C!61>=G36?3=<:!<;!?!O<HJ@Q51!414516!?3!?!d<5!G=31!<A16G1?GN!!
(14516GF=2! =G! A?J=@! ;<6! <:1! <:1! B<:36?B3! <;! 3O<! C1?6! @H6?3=<:N! P<6! A<JH:3?6C!
414516G! OF<! 61>=G316! ?3! ?! d<5! G=31I! 414516GF=2! @<1G! :<3! 1RB11@! 3O<! C1?6GN!!
(14516GF=2!GF?JJ!51!61:1O1@!H2<:!2?C41:3!<;!B<:36=5H3=<:!<:!B<:36?B3!61:1O?J![!
=GGH?:B1!<;!:1O!B<:36?B3N!%:!3F1!B?G1!<;!A<JH:3?6C!414516GF=2I!B<A16?>1!GF?JJ!51!
61:1O1@! H2<:! 2?C41:3! <;! B<:36=5H3=<:N! #../! 414516GF=2! =G! 3=1@! 3<! 3F1! #P.WG!
O<6K!B<:36?B3N!!!
*F1!BH4HJ?3=A1!B<:36=5H3=<:!<;!E0f7_N88!?H3<4?3=B?JJC!51B<41G!3F1!#../!;H:@!Q!
?!G=:>J1!36HG3!;H:@!2<<J1@!;6<4!3F1!414516GF=2!B<:36=5H3=<:G!<;!;<61=>:!142J<C16GI!
J?:@Q5?G1@! ?:@!G1?Q5?G1@! O<6K16GI! =:A1G341:3!?:@! =:3161G3! =:B<41I! ?:@! =:B<41!
;6<4!<3F16!G<H6B1GN!!&?31><6=U1@!?G!?!SH?G=Q><A16:41:3?J!1:3=3CI!=3!=G!1:3=61JC!G1J;Q
;H:@1@!?:@!61B1=A1G!:<!5H@>13!?JJ<B?3=<:!;6<4!3F1!:?3=<:?J!><A16:41:3N!
&"
!""#$%&'()*$+,-,*)*&,$./&-/01,*0$23(4$,5*$6*-4$7&0*0$8*'*)9*4$:;<$=>;>?$
"
AMOUNT'(Pesos)'
PERCENTAGE'
INCOME'
"
"
'()*(+,-./"0((,"
!1&&&123#14245%6"
375$"
89:(+(,:"89;<)("=.9>(,:)(9:?"
3&416&614!$5$%"
#75$"
@:-(+"89;<)("
#71&2&1&4356&"
!5$"
TOTAL'INCOME'
#1#%$1$471#22127"
!6656"
"
"
"
EXPENSES'
"
"
A(+,<9BC"D(+>.;(,"
%6#17%!1#%25!%"
!456"
'@@E"
#4#1!$714#65!7"
!#53"
A+<F+B),"G"D(+>.;(,"
26%1!4%12$$524"
$!5%"
TOTAL'EXPENSES'
!1$471#&3146!5!!"
3!57"
"
"
"
TOTAL'INCOME'
4&%1!#$1%23534"
$45!"
LG<H6B1X!!#../!/::H?J!+12<63!7898M!
*F1!:H4516!<;!#../!414516G!F?G!=:B61?G1@!<A16!3F1!C1?6GN!!/G!<;!1:@!<;!7898I!
#../! 1:6<JJ1@! 9I`__I``9! 414516GI! \Nag! F=>F16! B<42?61@! 3<! 9I7`^I97^!
1:6<JJ1@! =:! 788\N! ! *F=G! <:JC! =:@=B?31G! 3F1! B<:3=:H<HG! H2O?6@! 361:@! =:! #P.!
4=>6?3=<:N!
!""#$@*)9*4A51B$-&0$+*4C1'*A$!C*4$D5*$6*-4A$$
Overall'Client'
2006'
2007'
2008'
2010'
H<:BC"IC.(9:"D(+>(J"
2&!1673"
4!$13$%"
77&1%27"
!1#$#16!7"
K"89;+(B,("/(+"L(B+"
"
4"
!4"
2"
M(9(NBC"B9J"O'A"
7&%1!7!"
!1!6216$7"
!1#%#1&#%"
!1$&&1$$!"
K"89;+(B,("/(+"L(B+"
"
!%"
!!"
7"
""=,<Q+;(R""@SST"T99QBC"M(/<+:"#6!6?"
*F1! 3?5J1! ?5<A1! GF<OG! 3F1! =:B61?G=:>! 361:@! =:! 3F1! :H4516! <;! BJ=1:3G! G16A1@! 5C!
#../N! ! P6<4! 788b! 3<! 7898I! 3<3?J! BJ=1:3! G16A1@! =:B61?G1@! 5C! `\g! <6! ^a8I\7`!
414516G!G16A1@N!!*F1!?>1:BC!F?G!G16A1@!?!3<3?J!<;!9I7`7I89\!BJ=1:3G!B<42?61@!3<!
9I9_8I8b`! <;! J?G3! C1?6I! <6! ?:! =:B61?G1! <;!]gN!! -:6<JJ41:3!<;!#../!414516GF=2!
3F6<H>F!61:1O?J!?:@!A<JH:3?6C!414516GF=2!61>=G36?3=<:!<:QG=31!>61O!5C!`8g!;<6!3F1!
216=<@!788b!3<!7898N!!!
2::$·V PDQGDWH PD\ EH VXPPDUL]HG LQWR WZR ILUVWO\ WKH GHOLYHU\ RI ZHOIDUH
G16A=B1G! ?:@! 51:1;=3G! 3<! 3142<6?6C! 4=>6?:3! O<6K16GI! ?:@I! G1B<:@JCI! 1:GH6=:>!
GHG3?=:?5=J=3C! ?:@! ;H:@! A=?5=J=3C! ;<6! 3F1! B<:3=:H<HG! 26<31B3=<:! <;! P=J=2=:<! 4=>6?:3!
O<6K16GN! ! &<:G=G31:3! O=3F! =3G! 4?:@?31! ;<BHG=:>! <:! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;! 3F1! #P.G! ?:@!
3F1=6!;?4=J=1GI!3F1! 4?=:!26<>6?4G!<;!#../!=:BJH@1!L?M! F1?J3F!B?61I!@=G?5=J=3C!?:@!
@1?3F! 51:1;=3Gc! L5M! 1@HB?3=<:! ?:@! 36?=:=:>! 26<>6?4Gc! LBM! <:QG=31! ?GG=G3?:B1! ?:@!
G16A=B1Gc!L@M!!612?36=?3=<:c!?:@!L1M!!G<B=?J!G16A=B1G!?:@!;?4=JC!O1J;?61!?GG=G3?:B1N!
!
3"
,1?J3F!&?61!?:@!0<B=?J!V1:1;=3G!
%:! 7898I! #../! @1A1J<21@! 7! :1O!41@=B?J! 51:1;=3G! 26<>6?4G! =:!61G2<:G1! 3<! 3F1!
61SH1G3! ;<6! ?:! 1:F?:B1@! F1?J3F! 2?BK?>1! ²! 3F1! ,1?J3F! "6<>6?4! ;<6! #P.!
L,-/$*,"+#M! ?:@! 3F1! "Z.! (1@=B?J! +1F?5=J=3?3=<:! "6<>6?4N! ! *F1G1! :1O! F1?J3F!
51:1;=3! 2?BK?>1G! 26<A=@1@! F<G2=3?J=U?3=<:! 51:1;=3G! ?:@! 41@=B?J! 61F?5=J=3?3=<:!
G16A=B1G! 3<! #P.G! OF<! O161! @=?>:<G1@! O=3F! @61?@1@! @=G1?G1G! <6! GH;;16=:>! ;6<4!
J=:>16=:>!41:3?J!?:@!2FCG=B?J!=JJ:1GG1GN!
P<6!3F1!216=<@!788b!3<!7898I!3F1!3<3?J!:H4516!<;!BJ?=4?:3G!;<6!A?6=<HG!F1?J3F!B?61!
?:@!G<B=?J!51:1;=3G!=:B61?G1@!5C!4<61!3F?:!^8gN!!P<6!7898!?J<:1I!3F1!:H4516!<;!
BJ?=4?:3G!?GG=G31@!<:!3F1=6!BJ?=4G!G31221@!H2!3<!`I\8a!;6<4!7Ib\b!<;!788\N!
Types'of'Benefits'
2006'
2007'
2008'
2009'
2010'
U(B:-"B9J"VQ+.BC"
!1###"
!1$#4"
!1$2!"
!1&74"
!14%3"
U.,B*.C.:W1" U.,)()*(+)(9:" G" H<:BC"
U.,B*.C.:W"
$7&"
&42"
!1!!2"
!1674"
!1&#7"
XETYHXAM@"
"
"
"
"
&!2"
M(-B*"A+<F+B)"
"
"
"
"
!3"
H@HTY"
!13!2"
!17!&"
#1%44"
#1373"
$1764"
Percent'Increase'per'Year'
"
16'
23'
8'
31'
''(source:''OWWA'Annual'Report'2010)'
-@HB?3=<:!?:@!*6?=:=:>!V1:1;=3G!
#../! <;;16G! 3O<! 4?d<6! 1@HB?3=<:! 26<>6?4G! ;<6! J1?A=:>! 4=>6?:3! O<6K16GN! ! *F1!
&<4261F1:G=A1! "61QD12?63H61! -@HB?3=<:! "6<>6?4! L&"D-"M! =:BJH@1G! BHJ3H61!
;?4=J=?6=U?3=<:!?:@! J?:>H?>1! 36?=:=:>! 2JHG! ?:!<23=<:?J! ;=6G3! ?=@!36?=:=:>!?:@! G361GG!
4?:?>141:3N! ! *F=G! G3?631@! =:! 788]! ?:@! =G! 5?G=B?JJC! @1G=>:1@! ;<6! ?5<H3Q3<QJ1?A1!
F<HG1F<J@! G16A=B1! O<6K16G! L,0.GM! 4<G3! <;! OF<4! ?61! @<41G3=B! O<6K16GN!!
(?:@?3<6C! 261Q@12?63H61! <6=1:3?3=<:! G14=:?6G! L"D#0M! F1J2! 5H=J@! GK=JJ! G13G! ?:@!
;?4=J=?6=U1!O<HJ@Q51!4=>6?:3G!O=3F!3F1!BHJ3H61!?:@!26?B3=B1G!<;!3F1=6!F<G3!B<H:36=1GN!!
021B=;=B! 4<@HJ1G! ?61! BHG3<4=U1@! ;<6! @<41G3=B! O<6K16GI! 216;<64=:>! ?63=G3G! ?:@!
1:3163?=:16GI! :H6G1GI! ?:@! G1?;?616GI! ?G! O1JJ! ?G! ;<6! O<6K16G! 4=>6?3=:>! 3<! B163?=:!
B<H:36=1G[61>=<:GI! GHBF!?G! ,<:>! Y<:>I! $=5C?I! 3F1! (=@@J1!-?G3I! 0<H3F! Y<61?I! ?:@!
*?=O?:N!%:!B<:@HB3=:>!3F1G1!G14=:?6GI!#../!2?63:16G!O=3F!414516G!<;!3F1!26=A?31!
G1B3<6!L1N>NI!UHFUXLWPHQWDJHQFLHVDQGDVVRFLDWLRQVDQGFLYLOVRFLHW\HJZRUNHUV·
>6<H2G!?:@!)Z#GMN!*F1!2?63:16G!B<:@HB3!3F1!<6=1:3?3=<:G!OF=J1!#../!2612?61G!3F1!
4?316=?JGI!G13G!G3?:@?6@!SH?J=;=B?3=<:GI!?:@!B<:@HB3G!36?=:=:>!;<6!36?=:16GN!
EF878$-&0$F8!+$G*&*H1'1-41*A$
PreHDeparture'Trainings'
2006'
2007'
2008'
2009'
2010'
IAUEA"
$3&1%26"
$3$1%24"
$721&7&"
$7713!&"
&46162%"
AU@D"
"
341$22"
361727"
!!21!43"
!421%4&"
''(source:''OWWA'Annual'Report'2010)'
2"
#../!?JG<!26<A=@1G!G1A16?J!K=:@G!<;!GBF<J?6GF=2!>6?:3G!?:@!36?=:=:>!<22<63H:=3=1G!
;<6!414516G!?:@I!=:!G<41!B?G1GI!3F1=6!@121:@1:3GN!!*F1G1!?61X!
0K=JJGQ;<6Q-42J<C41:3! 0BF<J?6GF=2! "6<>6?4! L0-0"M! Q! /! 31BF:=B?J! <6! A<B?3=<:?J!
36?=:=:>! ?BB61@=31@! 5C! ><A16:41:3! =:G3=3H3=<:G! >6?:31@! 3<! 414516Q#P.G! <6! 3F1=6!
@121:@1:3G[51:1;=B=?6=1G! =:! 3F1! ;<64! <;! ;=:?:B=?J! ?GG=G3?:B1! <;! "F29^I_88N88!
4?R=4H4N!
(=B6<G<;3!*HJ?C!Q!/!G21B=?J!26<d1B3!=:!2?63:16GF=2!O=3F!(=B6<G<;3!&<62<6?3=<:!OF=BF!
26<A=@1G!=:;<64?3=<:!?:@!B<44H:=B?3=<:!31BF:<J<>C!36?=:=:>!>6?:31@!3<!#P.G!?:@!
3F1=6!;?4=J=1G!3<!56<?@1:!3F1=6!B?6116!<22<63H:=3=1GN!
-@HB?3=<:!;<6!D1A1J<241:3!0BF<J?6GF=2!"6<>6?4!L-D0"M!Q!/!GBF<J?6GF=2!>6?:31@!3<!
SH?J=;=1@!@121:@1:3G[51:1;=B=?6=1G!<;!?B3=A1!414516Q#P.G!;<6!?!B<JJ1>1!@1>611!L^Q
_!C1?6GMI!=:!3F1!;<64!<;!;=:?:B=?J!?GG=G3?:B1!<;!"F2!b8I888N88!216!GBF<<J!C1?6N!
#P.QD121:@1:3G! 0BF<J?6GF=2! "6<>6?4! L#P.D0"MQ! 26<A=@1G! 3F1! #P.G! <6! 3F1=6!
V1:1;=B=?6=1GI!3F1! <22<63H:=3C!3<!?BSH=61! A<B?3=<:?JI!31BF:=B?J!<6!G21B=?J=U1@! GK=JJG!
3F6<H>F! 3F1! #P.D0"N! *F=G! 26<>6?4! <;;16G! ;=:?:B=?J! ?GG=G3?:B1! 3<! SH?J=;=1@!
@121:@1:3G! <;! #P.G! OF<! ?61! 1?6:=:>! ?! 4<:3FJC! G?J?6C! <;! :<3! 4<61! 3F?:!
E0f^88N88!?:@!OF<!GF?JJ!1:6<JJ!=:!?:C!;<H6QC1?6!<6!;=A1QC1?6!5?BB?J?H61?31!B<H6G1!
<6! ?GG<B=?31! B<H6G1! J1?@=:>! 3<! ?! 5?BB?J?H61?31! @1>611! <6! ?GG<B=?31! @1>611! =:! ?!
G3?31!B<JJ1>1!<6!H:=A16G=3CN!
-@HB?3=<:!?:@!$=A1J=F<<@!/GG=G3?:B1!"6<>6?4!L-$/"M!;<6!D121:@1:3G!<;!D1B1?G1@!
#P.G!=G!@1G=>:1@!26=4?6=JC!;<6!GH6A=A<6G!<;!@1B1?G1@!#P.G!OF<!O161!?B3=A1!#../!
414516G!H:3=J!3F1=6!3=41!<;!@1?3FN!*F1!26<>6?4!F?G!7!B<42<:1:3G!²!?:!-@HB?3=<:!
"?BK?>1! =:31:@1@! 3<! B<A16! B<:3=:H<HG! 1@HB?3=<:! <;! ?:! 1J=>=5J1! @121:@1:3!
61>?6@J1GG! <;! F=G! 1@HB?3=<:?J! J1A1J! H:3=J! B<42J13=<:! <;! 3163=?6C! 1@HB?3=<:! <6! ?!
31BF:=B?J[A<B?3=<:?J! B<H6G1! <;! F=G! 261;161:B1c! ?:@! ?! $=A1J=F<<@! "?BK?>1! 3<! ?!
GH6A=A=:>!414516!<;!3F1!;?4=JC!3<!?H>41:3!3F1=6!=:B<41N!
6HDIDUHUV·8SJUDG=:>!"6<>6?4!L0E"M!Q!/!36?=:=:>!?GG=G3?:B1!3<!414516QG1?;?616G!=:!
H2>6?@=:>! 3F1=6! GK=JJG! ?:@! B<42131:B=1G! 3<! GHG3?=:! 3F1=6! 142J<C?5=J=3C! <:! 5<?6@!
;<61=>:Q><=:>!A1GG1JG!=:!3F1!;<64!<;!;=:?:B=?J!?GG=G3?:B1!<;!"F2]I_88N88N!
(?6=3=41!DH>3<:>!/6?J!L(D/M! Q!/!GBF<J?6GF=2!>6?:31@!3<!SH?J=;=1@!>6?@H?31G!<;!V0!
(1BF?:=B?J! -:>=:116=:>!LV0(-M! <6! V0! -J1B36=B?J!-:>=:116=:>! LV0--MI! OF<! O=GF! 3<!
2H6GH1!?!V0!(?6=:1!-:>=:116=:>!LV0(?6-M!&<H6G1N!
&?@13GF=2! "6<>6?4! ;<6! *<2! 788! (?6=3=41! &?@13G! L&/D-*0,%"M! Q! /! ;=:?:B=?J!
=:B1:3=A1!>6?:31@!3<!3F1!3<2!788!B?@13G!LD1BK!?:@!-:>=:1M!3<!1:GH61!B<42J13=<:!<;!
3F1=6!B<H6G1!?:@!142J<C?5=J=3C!<:!5<?6@!;<61=>:Q><=:>!A1GG1JN!
(?6%3=41! -@HB?3=<:?J! D1A1J<241:3! $<?:! "6<>6?4! L(-D$#"M! Q! /:! =:3161G3! ;611!
1@HB?3=<:?J! J<?:! L03H@C! )<O! "?C! $?316M! 3<! 26<G21B3=A1! 4?6=:1! <;;=B16G! ?:@!
1:>=:116G!O=3F!>H?6?:311@!142J<C41:3!<:Q5<?6@!;<61=>:Q><=:>!A1GG1JN!
4"
^ĐŚŽůĂƌƐŚŝƉWƌŽŐƌĂŵƐ͛ĞŶĞĨŝĐŝĂƌŝĞƐ'
Types'of'Trainings'
2006'
2007'
2008'
2009'
2010'
DEDA"
!174!"
!162!"
#1!72"
$1!#7"
&13##"
'.;+<,<Z:"HQCBW"
%1&64"
&146#"
41#66"
!$1#!6"
!%136!"
EUDA"
$37"
!43"
#%&"
&%&"
%7%"
@0SUDA"
"
"
"
"
#77"
EYTA"
"
"
"
"
$$7"
D[A"
#1!22"
$177#"
&12!7"
21#2#"
71&26"
'UT"
"
"
!62"
4%"
24"
ITUEHDX8A"
"
"
"
"
!44"
'EUY@A"
"
"
"
"
7"
H@HTY"
716$&"
!!16&!"
!31%34"
#%1#%6"
$$1#4#"
%'Increase'per'Year'
'
18'
33'
32'
27'
(source:''OWWA'Annual'Report'2010)'
+12?36=?3=<:!"6<>6?4!
*F=G! 26<>6?4! 26<A=@1G! G16A=B1GI! =:BJH@=:>! :1><3=?3=<:G! O=3F! 142J<C16GI! ?>1:3GI!
?:@!F<G3!B<H:36C!?H3F<6=3=1GI!3<!;?B=J=3?31!3F1!=441@=?31!612?36=?3=<:!<;!#P.G!OF<!
?61! @=G361GG1@! <6! 2FCG=B?JJC[41:3?JJC! =JJ! ?:@! FH4?:! 614?=:GN! *F1C! ?61! >=A1:!
?=62<63!?GG=G3?:B1I!@<41G3=B!36?:G2<63I!3142<6?6C!GF1J316I!41@=B?J[61F?5=J=3?3=<:!
G16A=B1GI!?:@!B<<6@=:?3=<:!O=3F!;?4=J=1GN!
*F1!3?5J1!51J<O!GF<OG!3F1!166?3=B!;=>H61!=:!3F1!:H4516!<;!#P.G!612?36=?31@!O=3F!
3F1! ?GG=G3?:B1! <;! #../N! !+12?36=?3=<:! =:!788b! O?G!4?=:JC! @H1!3<! 3F1!2<J=3=B?J!
B6=G=G! =:! $15?:<:I! OF=J1! 788\! ;=>H61G! O161! 4?=:JC! @H1! 3<! 3F1! 3164=:?3=<:! <;!
B<:36?B3G! =:!B<H:36=1G! ?;;1B31@!5C! 3F1!>J<5?J! ;=:?:B=?J! B6=G=GN!! 7898!612?36=?3=<:!
1;;<63G! O161! 4?=:JC! 1R31:@1@! 3<! 3F<G1! G36?:@1@[F<HG1@! =:! O1J;?61! B1:316G! =:!
h1@@?FI!h<6@?:I!YHO?=3I!V1=6H3I!/5H!DF?5=!?:@!+=C?@FN!
Beneficiaries'of'the'OWWA'Repatriation'Assistance'
Repatriation'Program'
2006'
2007'
2008'
2009'
2010'
@9P,.:("M(/B:+.B:.<9"T,,.,:B9;( "
!#1666"
71%!7"
416#3"
71#&#"
3177#"
E)(+F(9;W" M(/B:+.B:.<9" A+<F+B)"
=:.;\(:?"
314$%"
!1%33"
&2!"
!176$"
#1#7%"
T.+/<+:"T,,.,:B9;("
!!12&7"
&1&72"
&1&$4"
3173#"
312!7"
XBCZNBW"X<)("T;;<))<JB:.<9"
&16$6"
!14#!"
!17#%"
#1#$!"
#1426"
'(J.;BC"M(Z(++BC"
#4%"
%&"
27"
7$$$"
2"
U<)(,:.;"H+B9,/<+:B:.<9"
317%&"
$62"
23!"
72$"
!1!3#"
H@HTY"
%#14&#"
!413&&"
!31477"
#!1%!%"
#616%%"
(source:''OWWA'Annual'Report'2010)'
0<B=?J!016A=B1G!?:@!P?4=JC!.1J;?61!
+1=:31>6?3=<:!26<>6?4!B<A16G!3O<!L7M!4?d<6!B<42<:1:3G! ²!1B<:<4=B!?:@!2GCBF<Q
G<B=?J!B<42<:1:3GN!!*F1!1B<:<4=B!B<42<:1:3!<:!3F1!<3F16!F?:@I!=:BJH@1G!G<B=?J!
2612?6?3=<:! 26<>6?4G! ;<6! J=A1J=F<<@! 26<d1B3G! <6! B<44H:=3CQ5?G1@! =:B<41!
>1:16?3=:>! 26<d1B3GI! GK=JJG! 36?=:=:>! ?:@! B61@=3! ;?B=J=3?3=<:! ?:@! J1:@=:>N! /3! 261G1:3I!
7"
3F1! 1B<:<4=B!B<42<:1:3! F?G! 3O<! L7M! J<?:! 26<>6?4GX!3F1! #../Q)$0P! $=A1J=F<<@!
D1A1J<241:3!"6<>6?4G!;<6!#P.G!L$D"#M!?:@!3F1!#P.!Z6<B16=?!"6<d1B3N!
*F1!#../Q)$0P!$=A1J=F<<@!D1A1J<241:3!"6<>6?4!=G!?!d<=:3!H:@163?K=:>!<;!#../!
?:@!)?3=<:?J!$=A1J=F<<@!0H22<63!PH:@!L)$0PMN!3<!?@@61GG!3F1!1B<:<4=B!B<42<:1:3!
<;! 3F1! #P.! +1=:31>6?3=<:! "6<>6?4N! ! %3! =G! 41?:3! 3<! ;H63F16! =426<A1! ?BB1GG! 3<!
1:361261:1H6=?J! @1A1J<241:3! <22<63H:=3=1G! ?:@! B61@=3! ;?B=J=3=1G! 3<! #P.GI! 3F1=6!
;?4=J=1GI!?:@!<6>?:=U?3=<:GN!
*F1!#P.!Z6<B16=?!26<d1B3!=G!?:!=:3161G3Q;611!J<?:!?GG=G3?:B1!2?BK?>1!1R31:@1@!=:!
3F1! ;<64! <;! 416BF?:@=G1! ><<@G! O<63F! "_8I888! 216! SH?J=;=1@! #P.! P?4=JC! &=6BJ1!
51:1;=B=?6C! ?! G16=1G! <;! B<:3=:H=:>! GK=JJG! 36?=:=:>! B<H6G1G! ?61! ?JG<! 26<A=@1@! 3<!
1:F?:B1!3F1!1:361261:1H6=?J!?:@!31BF:=B?J!GK=JJG!<;!3F1!;?4=JC!B=6BJ1G!6H::=:>!?:@!
4?:?>=:>!3F1=6!G3<61GN!
#../!?JG<!B?41!<H3!O=3F!3F1!P=J=2=:<!-R2?36=?31!$=A1J=F<<@!0H22<63!PH:@!LP-$0PM!
?G!G?;13C! :13!;<6!3F1=6! @=G2J?B141:3!@H1!3<! 3F1!>J<5?J!;=:?:B=?J!B6=G=GN! /;316!#P.G!
F?A1!?A?=J1@!<;!?GG=G3?:B1!;6<4!3F1!)?3=<:?J!+1=:31>6?3=<:!&1:316!;<6!#P.G!L)+&#M!
;<6! 3F1! =:=3=?J! ?GG=G3?:B1! 2?BK?>1I! ?:C! =:3161G31@! #P.! 4?C! ?A?=J! <;! 3F1! P-$0PI!
OF=BF!<;;16G!?!)<:QB<JJ?316?J!$<?:!.=:@<O!OF161!3F1!@=G2J?B1@!#P.G!B?:!J<?:!H2!
3<!;=;3C!3F<HG?:@!21G<G!L"F2_8I888N88M!O=3F!?!A16C!J<O!=:3161G3!<;!;=A1!216B1:3!L_gM!
216! ?::H4I! 2?C?5J1! =:! 7^! 4<:3FGN!Z<A16:41:3! 5?:KG! B?:! ?JG<! 1R31:@! J<?:G!
3F6<H>F! 3F1=6! B<JJ?316?J! O=:@<OG! =;! O<6K16! @1B=@1G! 3<! 1R2?:@! F=G! 5HG=:1GG!
1:31626=G1N!
ǀĂŝůĞĞƐŽĨKtt͛Ɛ>ŝǀĞůŝŚŽŽĚWƌŽŐƌĂŵ'
Types'of'Livelihood'
2006'
2007'
2008'
2009'
2010'
@SSTP]YD0"YUA@"
!74"
$$%"
#&4"
#!2"
#6$"
0EYD0"
"
"
"
%1%2%"
%14#!"
^+<;(+.B"A+<_(;:"
#3!"
#%!"
%32"
"
"
H@HTY"
%&7"
&2&"
74$"
%137!"
&16#%"
'(source:''OWWA'Annual'Report'2010)'
#../!V-'#)D!*,-!)E(V-+0!
$QLQVWLWXWLRQ·VHIIHFWLYHQHVVDQG HIILFLHQF\ZRXOG EH EHVWDQDO\]HGE\LWV FOLHQWV
P<6! #../I! =3! =G! 51G3! G11:! 3F6<H>F! 3F1! 216G21B3=A1! <;! =3G! 414516GN! ! P<6! 3F1!
"F=J=22=:1GI! ?! PDMRU RULJLQ FRXQWU\ RI PLJUDQWV 2::$·V SHUIRUPDQFH JLYHV DQ
<A16A=1O!<;! 3F1!O1J;?61!G16A=B1G! 3F?3!3F1!><A16:41:3! 26<A=@1G!3<! =3G! B=3=U1:G!OF<!
?61!O<6K=:>!?56<?@N!!/J3F<H>F!:<3!?!@13?=J1@!216;<64?:B1!1A?JH?3=<:!<;!"F=J=22=:1!
26<>6?4GI! 3F1! G3?3141:3G! 51J<O! 26<A=@1! ?:! H:@16G3?:@=:>! <;! 3F1! 2<J=B=1GI!
;H:B3=<:GI! ?:@! BF?JJ1:>1G! 3F?3! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! ><A16:41:3! ?@@61GG1G! 3F6<H>F! ?!
H:=SH1!><A16:41:3!=:G3=3H3=<:I!3F1!#../I!3<!26<31B3!=3G!O<6K16G!?56<?@N!
#P.G!F?A1!B<42J?=:1@!<;!3F1!@=;;=BHJ3=1G!=:!?A?=J=:>!<;!#../!51:1;=3G!?:@!G16A=B1G!
@H1! 3<! 5H61?HB6?3=B! 26<B1@H61G!?:@! J?BK!<;! ?GG=G3?:B1!;6<4! =3G!216G<::1JN! 0<41!
F?A1! SH1G3=<:1@! 3F1! J?BK! <;! #P.! 61261G1:3?3=<:! =:! 3F1! #../! V<?6@! ?:@! =3G!
@1B=G=<:G!3F?3! F?A1!:<3!51:1;=31@!3F1! <A16G1?G!P=J=2=:<!O<6K16GN! (?:C!#P.G!?:@!
!6"
4=>6?:3! O<6K16! ?@A<B?31G! F?A1! B?JJ1@! <:! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! ><A16:41:3! 3<! 61;<64!
#../!?:@!3<!4?K1!=3!4<61!61G2<:G=A1!3<!3F1!:11@G!<;!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!!
*<!;H63F16!1JHB=@?31!3F1G1!B<:B16:GI!3F1!&1:316!;<6!(=>6?:3!/@A<B?BC!B<:@HB31@!?:!
<:J=:1!GH6A1C!=:!788aI!<;!#P.G!3<!<53?=:!=:;<64?3=<:!?5<H3!3F1=6!H:@16G3?:@=:>!<;!
#../!²!=3G!G16A=B1GI!<216?3=<:GI!?:@!J1?@16GF=2!G36HB3H61N!*F1!GH6A1C!O?G!2<G31@!
<:!O15G=31G!<;!3F611!:<:26<;=3!<6>?:=U?3=<:G!OF=BF!?61!O<6K=:>!3<!26<31B3!3F1!6=>F3G!
?:@!O1J;?61! <;! #P.GN! /!3<3?J! <;!^88! #P.G!61G2<:@1@!?:@! B<42J131@!3F1! GH6A1CN!
*F1!61G2<:@1:3G!=:BJH@1@!41:!?:@!O<41:!<;!A?6=<HG!?>1!>6<H2G!OF<!?61!O<6K=:>!
=:! 3F1!(=@@J1!-?G3I! /G=?I!/;6=B?I! &?:?@?!?:@! -H6<21!=:! 5<3F!F=>FQGK=JJ1@! ?:@! J<OQ
GK=JJ1@!d<5!G1B3<6GN!
%:316A=1O! SH1G3=<:G! ;<BHG1@! <:! ;<HU PDMRU LVVXHV FHQWUDO WR 2::$·V UROH RI
26<A=@=:>!G16A=B1G!?:@!4?=:3?=:=:>!;H:@!G3?5=J=3CN!!*F1G1!?61!414516GF=2I!51:1;=3G!
?:@!G16A=B1GI!?@4=:=G36?3=<:!?:@!B<44H:=B?3=<:I!
(14516GF=2!=:!#../!
! #../! 1:?B31@! 3F1! #4:=5HG! "<J=B=1G! <:! 012314516! 9\I! 788`! 3F6<H>F! V<?6@!
+1G<JH3=<:! )<N! `aN! *F1! #4:=5HG!"<J=B=1G! =:BJH@1@!3F1! 61SH=6141:3G! 3<!SH?J=;C!?G!
#../! 414516GI! 3F1! ?4<H:3! <;! 3F1! B<:36=5H3=<:! 3F?3! 4HG3! 51! 2?=@! 5C! 3F1!
142J<C16I!?:@!414516GF=2!@H6?3=<:N!!
OWWA'Membership''
'
Questions'
Number'
who' said'
͞zĞƐ͟;йͿ'
Number'
who' said'
͞EŽ͟;йͿ'
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" @SST" )()*(+,-./" .,"
)B9JB:<+W" Z<+" BCC" <>(+,(B," N<+\(+," N-<,(" ;<9:+B;:," B+("
/+<;(,,(J"*W"A@ET`"=9a$47?"
"
$$7"
=425!&?"
&6"
=!#54&?"
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" <>(+,(B," N<+\(+," )BW" (9+<CC"
><CQ9:B+.CW"N.:-"@SST"B:"_<*",.:(,"<>(+,(B,`"=9a$44?"
"
!3!""
=%!5%7?"
##2"
=&45&!?"
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" @SST" *(9(Z.:," B+(" <9CW"
B>B.CB*C(" :<" @0S," N-<" B+(" @SST" )()*(+," B9J" -B>("
/B.J":-("[Db#&")()*(+,-./"Z((`"=9a$42?"
"
$6$"
=245#7?"
4%"
=#!52!?"
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" @SST" )()*(+,-./" ;<9:.9Q(,"
Q9:.C": -("(c/.+B:.<9"<Z":-(";<9:+B;:".Z"/+<;(,,(J"*W"A@ET1"
<+" Z<+" #" W(B+," .Z" +(F.,:(+(J" :-+<QF-" ><CQ9:B+W" <9P,.:("
+(F.,:+B:.<9`"=9a$4$?"
"
!7%"
=&653&?"
"
!47"
=%75$&?"
!!"
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" :-(" ()/C<W(+" .," ,Q//<,(J" :<"
,-<QCJ(+":-(";<,:"<Z":-("@SST")()*(+,-./"Z((`"=9a$4%?"
"
"
3#"
=!35!&?"
"
$##"
=4$54&?"
!
*F1! 61GHJ3G! GF<O1@! 3F?3! a]g! <;! #P.! 61G2<:@1:3G! O161! ?O?61! 3F?3! #../!
414516GF=2!=G!4?:@?3<6C!;<6!?JJ!<A16G1?G!O<6K16G!OF<G1!B<:36?B3G!?61!26<B1GG1@!
5C! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! #A16G1?G! -42J<C41:3! /@4=:=G36?3=<:N! ,<O1A16I! _\g! O161! :<3!
?O?61!3F?3!3F1C!B<HJ@!A<JH:3?6=JC!?22JC!?G!414516G!?3!3F1=6!d<5!G=31GN!
*F1! 61GHJ3G! ?JG<! GF<O1@! 3F?3! ]ag! <;! 3F1! 61G2<:@1:3G! O161! ?O?61! 3F?3! #../!
51:1;=3G!?61!<:JC! ?A?=J?5J1!3<! 3F<G1!OF<! 2?=@! 3F1!414516GF=2!;11N!,<O1A16I! <:JC!
BJ<G1!3<!F?J;!L^\gM!K:1O!<;!3F1!@H6?3=<:!<;!414516GF=2I!3F?3!=G!H:3=J!3F1!1R2=6?3=<:!
<;! 3F1=6! B<:36?B3G! =;! 26<B1GG1@! 5C! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! #A16G1?G! -42J<C41:3!
/@4=:=G36?3=<:!?:@!;<6!3O<!C1?6G!=;!26<B1GG1@!3F6<H>F!A<JH:3?6C!<:QG=31!61>=G36?3=<:N!
/226<R=4?31JC! a^g!<;! 3F1! 61G2<:@1:3G! O161! :<3!?O?61! 3F?3! 3F1! 414516GF=2! ;11!
GF<HJ@!51!GF<HJ@161@!5C!3F1=6!142J<C16GN!*F=G!GF<O1@!3F?3!#P.G!51J=1A1@!3F?3!3F1C!
F?@!3<!2?C!3F1=6!414516GF=2!;11GN!
! &<441:3G! ;6<4! 3F1! 61G2<:@1:3G! 61;J1B31@! @=;;161:B1G! =:! 3F1=6! A=1OG! ?5<H3! 3F1!
4?:@?31!<;!#../N!0<41!#P.G!51J=1A1@!3F?3!#../!GF<HJ@!26<A=@1!G16A=B1G!3<!=3G!
414516G!<:JC!OF=J1!<3F16G!G?=@!3F?3!#../!GF<HJ@!26<31B3!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!?JJ!#P.GI!
UHJDUGOHVV RIPHPEHUVKLS $Q 2): VDLG WKDW ´,W LV XQIDLU LI QRQQ#../! 414516G!
?61! 1:3=3J1@!3<! 3F1!51:1;=3G! ?22J=B?5J1!3<! 3F1!#../! 414516G!OF<! 61>HJ?6JC! 2?=@!
WKHPHPEHUVKLSIHHµ+RZHYHUVRPH2):VSRLQWHGRXWWKDWHYHQPHPEHUVUDUHO\
HQMR\ WKH 2::$ EHQHILWV $QRWKHU 2): VDLG WKDW ´WKH PDMRULW\ RI 3LQR\ ZRUNHUV
QHHGLQJKHOSDEURDGDUHXQUHJLVWHUHGRUXQGRFXPHQWHGµDQGPRVWOLNHO\ZRXOGQRW
51!#../! 41451UV2WKHU 2):V UHMHFWHG WKH´PHPEHUQRQQPHPEHUµ GLFKRWRP\
51B?HG1! 3F1C! 51J=1A1@! =3! =G! 3F1! 61G2<:G=5=J=3C! <;! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! Z<A16:41:3! 3<!
1:GH61!3F?3!#../!26<31B31@!?JJ!#P.G!5?G1@!<:!=3G!4?:@?31N!!
!!!!OWWA'Benefits'and'Services'
Questions'on'benefit'package''
'
Number'
who' said'
͞zĞƐ͟;йͿ'
Number'
who' said'
͞EŽ͟;йͿ'
Number'
who' said'
͞EΎ͟;йͿ'
"
x U<" W<Q" :-.9\" :-B: " @SST" *(9(Z.:,"
,-<QCJ" *(" C.).:(J" :<" @SST" )()*(+,"
N-<"/BW":-(")()*(+,-./"Z((`"=9"a"$42?"
"
"
$6$"
=245#7?"
"
4%"
=#!52!?"
P"
P"
"
x T+("W<Q"BNB+(":-B:"@SST"<ZZ(+,"C.Z("
.9,Q+B9;(1" J.,B*.C.:W" B9J" *Q+.BC" *(9(Z.:,1"
:+B.9.9F" B9J" ,;-<CB+,-./" /+<F+B),1"
+(/B:+.B:.<9" /+<F+B)," Z<+" J.,:+(,,(J"
@0S," B9J" :-(.+" ZB).C.(,1" +(.9:(F+B:.<9"
/+<F+B),1" C<B9," B9J" N<+\(+," B,,.,:B9;("
B9J"<9P,.:(",(+>.;(,`"=9a$44?"
"
"
#6#"
=&#563?"
"
"
!43"
=%257%?"
P"
P"
!#"
"
"
x XB>(" W<Q" Q,(J" B9W" <Z" :-(,("
/+<F+B),`"=9a$4%?"
"
"
#3"
=3522?"
"
$&4"
=7$5#$?"
P"
P"
"
x 8Z" W<Q" -B>(" B>B.C(J" <Z" B9W" <Z" :-(,("
,(+>.;(,1"NB,".:",Q;;(,,ZQC".9")((:.9F"W<Q+"
N(CZB+("9((J,`"=9a$&!?"
"
"
!3"
=&5!$?"
"
7$"
=#35&6"
#%6"
=345$4?"
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" @SST" .,"
;Q++(9:CW":-("C(BJ"N(CZB+(".9,:.:Q:.<9":-B:"
,((\," :<" ,(+>(" :-(" .9:(+(,:," B9J" N(CZB+("
<Z")()*(+,`"=9a$4#?"
"
"
!7#"
=&65#3?"
"
!76"
=%752%?"
P"
P"
"
x T+("W<Q"BNB+(":-B:":-("@SST"ZQ9J"
.," B>B.CB*C(" Z<+" C<B9," :<" 9<9P@0S"
*Q,.9(,,)(9`"=9a$24?"
"
"
#%"
=35$&?"
"
$&%"
=7$53&?"
P"
P"
"
x U<" W<Q" :-.9\" :-B:":-(" @SST"ZQ9J,"
,-<QCJ" *(" )BJ(" B>B.CB*C(" :<" 9<9P@0S"
C<B9,`"=9a$24?"
"
"
$3"
=!656&?"
"
$%6"
=4757&?"
P"
P"
"
x S-<" J<" W<Q" :-.9\" ,-<QCJ" ,-<QCJ(+"
:-(" ;<,:" <Z" @0S" N(CZB+(" ,(+>.;(,`"
=9a2$4?"
"
E)/C<W(+""
"
"
H-("@0S,":-(),(C>(,"
"
"
H-("A-.C.//.9("F<>(+9)(9:"
"
"
H-("Z<+(.F9"F<>(+9)(9:"
"
"
TCC"<Z":-("B*<>("
"
"
"
"
"
!27"
=#%5#&?"
"
!!3"
=!&52#?"
"
#&3"
=$%54#?"
""
"4$"
=!!5#&?"
"
!6$"
=!$573?"
"
"
"
P"
P"
P"
P"
"
"
P"
P"
P"
P"
!!!i)/X!:<3!?22J=B?5J1!
!$"
*F1! 61GHJ3G! GF<O1@! 3F?3! ]ag! <;! #P.! 61G2<:@1:3G! 51J=1A1! 3F?3! #../! 51:1;=3G!
GF<HJ@!51!J=4=31@!3<!=3G!414516GN!!/6<H:@!^ag!<;!#P.G!612<631@!3F?3!3F1C!@=@!:<3!
K:<O!OF?3!G16A=B1G!?:@!51:1;=3G!?61!<;;161@!5C!#../N!#;!3F1!GH6A1C!61G2<:@1:3GI!
<:JC! ]! 216B1:3! <;! #P.G! F?A1! GHBB1GG;HJJC! ?BB1GG1@!?:! #../! G16A=B1! <6! 51:1;=3!
?:@! _g! G?=@! 3F?3! 3F1=6! :11@G! O161! 413N! #;! 3F1! \`g! <;! #P.G! OF<! F?A1! :<3!
51:1;=31@!;6<4!?:!#../!26<>6?4I!?!4?d<6=3C!612<631@!3F?3!3F1C!F?@!:<3!?BB1GG1@!
3F1!51:1;=3!@H1!3<!J?BK!<;!=:;<64?3=<:!<6!5H61?HB6?3=B!26<B1@H61G!6?3F16!3F?:!;6<4!
J?BK! <;! :11@N! *F1! 61GHJ3G! ;H63F16! GF<O1@! 3F?3! F?J;! <;! 61G2<:@1:3G! L_8gM! @=@! :<3!
K:<O!3F?3!#../!=G!3F1!J1?@!><A16:41:3!?>1:BC!4?:@?31@!3<!26<31B3!3F1!O1J;?61!
<;!#P.GN!!
0<41!61G2<:@1:3G!G?=@!3F?3!#../!@<1G!:<3!G16A1!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!#P.GN!%:G31?@I!=3!
VHUYHVDV D´PLONLQJFRZµ IRU RWKHUJRYHUQPHQWDJHQFLHV !%:! ?@@=3=<:I! 612<63G!<;!
#../!J1:@=:>!B?2=3?J!3<!26=A?31!5HG=:1GG!>6<H2G!?:@!B<62<6?3=<:G!>?A1!#P.G!3F1!
=4261GG=<:!3F?3!G<41!21<2J1!O161!HG=:>!3F1!?>1:BC!;<6!3F1=6!<O:!26=A?31!=:3161G3GN!!
&<441:3G! ;6<4! 61G2<:@1:3G! ?JG<! GF<O1@! 3F?3! BH661:3! 26<B1@H61G! 3<! ?A?=J! <;!
51:1;=3G! 2<G1! =:GH64<H:3?5J1! <5G3?BJ1G! ;<6! 4<G3! #P.GN! 0<41! #P.G! B=31@! 3F1!
#../! 5H61?HB6?BC! ?G! <:1! <;! 3F1! 4?=:! 26<5J14G! 261A1:3=:>! 3F1! ?>1:BC! ;6<4!
;HJ;=JJ=:>! =3G! 4?:@?31! 3<! 26<31B3! #P.GN! ! /226<R=4?31JC! \`g! <;! #P.! 61G2<:@1:3G!
F?A1!:1A16!?A?=J1@!<;!?:!#../!51:1;=3N!!
+1G2<:@1:3G! @1GB6=51@! 3F1=6! B<44<:! 1R216=1:B1G! =:! <53?=:=:>! 51:1;=3G! ;6<4!
#../N!*F1! #../!216G<::1J!3<J@!3F1!#P.G!3F?3!3F1!51:1;=3G!O161!GHG21:@1@!<6!
:<!J<:>16!?A?=J?5J1N!P<6!3F<G1!OF<!2H6GH1@!3F1!51:1;=3G!?:@!G16A=B1GI!3F1C!F?@!3<!
H:@16><!?! 5H61?HB6?3=B! 26<B1GG!3F?3!HJ3=4?31JC! J1@!3<! F<21J1GG:1GG!?:@!3F1! #P.!
>=A=:>! H2N! V1B?HG1! <;! 3F=G! 612H3?3=<:! O=3F=:! 3F1! #P.! B<44H:=3CI! G<41! #P.G! =:!
GLVWUHVVGRQRWDWDOODSSO\IRU2::$DVVLVWDQFH$VRQH2):UHSRUWHG´,QHYHUJHW
?!><<@!;11@5?BK!;6<4!3F<G1!OF<!?J61?@C!1R216=1:B1@!L?GK=:>!;<6!?GG=G3?:B1!;6<4M!
2::$µ0DQ\2):VEHOLHYHWKDWWKH2::$SURJUDPVH[LVWRQO\RQSDSHUWRPDNH
3F1!?>1:BC!J<<K!1;;1B3=A1!5H3!=:!61?J=3C!@<!:<3!51:1;=3!#P.GN!!
!%"
#../!/@4=:=G36?3=<:!
!
!!!"16B123=<:!<;!#../!/@4=:=G36?3=<:!
Questions' on' OWWA' administration' &'
leadership'
Number' who'
ƐĂŝĚ ͞zĞƐ͟
(%)'
Number' who'
ƐĂŝĚ͞EŽ͟;йͿ'
"
x T+("W<Q"BNB+(":-B:":-("@SST"*<B+J";CB.),"
:-(" +.F-:" :<" :(+).9B:(" <+" BC:(+" @S ST" *(9(Z.:,"
B9J",(+>.;(,"Q9.CB:(+BCCW`"=9a$46?"
"
#7"
=253$?"
$&!"
=7#5$2?"
"
x T+("W<Q"BNB+(" :-B:" @0S," )B\("Q/"<9CW" !2"
/(+;(9:"<Z":-("@SST"V<B+J`"=9a$43?"
"
!!"
=#54&?"
$2&"
=725!&?"
"
x U<" W<Q" :-.9\" @0S," -B>(" (9<QF-"
+(/+(,(9:B:.<9":<":-("@SST"V<B+J`"=9a$4!?"
"
4%"
=##56&?"
#72"
=2257&?"
"
x T+(" W<Q" BNB+(" :-B:" :-(" @SST" ZQ9J" .,"
ĐŽŶƐŝĚĞƌĞĚ Ă ͞ƚƌƵƐƚ ĨƵŶĚ͕͟ ďƵƚ ĚŽĞƐ ŶŽƚ ŚĂǀĞ
ŶĂŵĞĚ ͞ƚƌƵƐƚŽƌƐ͘ dƌƵƐƚĞĞƐ" <+" *(9(Z.;.B+.(,`"
=9a$27?"
"
&%"
=!%5#&?"
$#&"
=4&52&?"
"
x ƌĞ LJŽƵ ĂǁĂƌĞ ƚŚĂƚ Ktt ŚĂƐ Ă ͞ƚĂƌŐĞƚ
ŐƌŽǁƚŚƌĂƚĞ͟ĂŶĚŝƐƚƌLJŝŶŐƚŽŝŶĐƌĞĂƐĞƚŚĞƐŝnjĞŽĨ
:-("ZQ9J`"=9a$2$?"
"
%&"
=!#563?"
$#4"
=4257%?"
!
+1GHJ3G! ?5<A1! GF<O1@! 3F?3! \7g! <;! #P.! 61G2<:@1:3G! O161! :<3! ?O?61! 3F?3! 3F1!
#../! V<?6@! F?@! 3F1! 6=>F3! 3<! 3164=:?31! <6! ?J316! 3F1! 51:1;=3G! ?:@! G16A=B1GN!
/226<R=4?31JC! \]g! <;! 3F1! 61G2<:@1:3G!O161! ?JG<! :<3!?O?61! 3F?3! #P.G! 4?@1!H2!
<:JC! 9]g! <;! 3F1! #../! V<?6@! ?:@! ]ag! G?=@! 3F?3! 3F1! #P.! 61261G1:3?3=<:! =G! :<3!
GH;;=B=1:3N!%:!?@@=3=<:I!abg! <;!3F1!61G2<:@1:3G!@=@!:<3!K:<O!3F?3!3F1!#../!36HG3!
;H:@!@=@!:<3!F?A1!51:1;=B=?6=1G!:<6!3F?3!=3!F?G!?!3?6>13!>6<O3F!6?31!LaagMN!!
*6HG311G! ;6<4! 3F1! 4?:?>141:3! ?:@! J?5<6! G1B3<6G! ?61! 61B<441:@1@! 5C!
?226<26=?31!?>1:B=1G!?:@!?226<A1@!5C!3F1!#;;=B1!<;!3F1!"61G=@1:3I!OF=BF!J1?@G!3<!
WKHSROLWLFL]DWLRQRIWKHSURFHVV6RPHUHVSRQGHQWVVDLGWKDW´WKHVHOHFWLRQSURFHVV
<;! V<?6@! <;! *6HG311G! GF<HJ@! 51! 36?:G2?61:3! ?:@! 61GHJ3G! 4?@1! K:<O:! 3<! 3F1!
PHPEHUVKLSµ7KH\DOVRVDLGWKDW!
x !´2::$VKRXOGEHUXQE\DQH[Q#P.I!:<3!5C!?!SROLWLFDODSSRLQWHHµ!
!&"
x ´2::$VKRXOGEHUXQE\FRPSHWHQWH[SHULHQFHGIRUPHU2):VRUDWOHDVW
4?d<6=3C!<;!OF<4!?61!1RQ2):Vµ!
x ´jH?J=;=1@!216G<::1J!4HG3!51!?3!G3?K1!=:G31?@!<;!B<J<6=:>!=3!O=3F!2<J=3=B?J!
DSSRLQWHHVµ!
!
+1G2<:@1:3G!O161!?JG<!?GK1@!3F1!;<JJ<O=:>!SH1G3=<:GX!
!
x !.F<!@<!C<H!3F=:K!=G!61G2<:G=5J1!;<6!4?:?>=:>!3F1!36HG3k!
x !.F<! @<! C<H! 3F=:K! >=A1G! <6! B<:36=5H31G! 3F1! 4<:1C! 3F?3! 4?K1G! H2! 3F1!
#../!;H:@k!
x !P<6!OF<G1!51:1;=3!@<!C<H!3F=:K!3F1!36HG3!F?G!511:!B61?31@k!
#;!3F1!]_!61G2<:@1:3G!OF<!?:GO161@!3F1!3F611!SH1G3=<:GI!_a!L]]gM!=@1:3=;=1@!3F1!
#P.G!?G!3F1!26=:B=2?J!4?:?>16!<;!3F1!36HG3I!3F1!26=4?6C!B<:36=5H3<6!3<! 3F1! #../!
;H:@I! ?:@! 3F161;<61! 3F1! 6=>F3;HJ! 51:1;=B=?6CN! *F1! "F=J=22=:1! ><A16:41:3I!
61261G1:3?3=A1G! <;! ;<61=>:! 142J<C16GI! ?:@! 3F1! #../! J1?@16G! O161! =@1:3=;=1@! ?G!
G16A=:>!?!GH22<63=:>!6<J1!3<!3F1!#P.GN!
(?:C!#P.G! ?61! A16C!B<:B16:1@!3F?3!3F1!BH661:3! V<?6@!414516G! @<!:<3!26=<6=3=U1!
#P.!O1J;?61!?:@!@<!:<3!H:@16G3?:@!3F1!1R216=1:B1G!<;!#P.GN!/!:H4516!<;!#P.G!
B?JJ1@! ;<6! ?! F=>F16! 6?3=<! <;! #P.! 3<! :<:Q#P.! V<?6@! 414516G! ?:@! @14?:@1@! ?!
%RDUGFRPSRVHGRI´216G<:G!O=3F!K:<O:!=:31>6=3C!?:@!61B<6@µ!
5HJDUGLQJWKHWUXVWHHV·XVHRIWKH!;H:@GI!61G2<:@1:3G!G?=@!3F?3X!!
x ´,W VKRXOG DQG PXVW VHUYH H[FOXVLYHO\ WKH QHHGV RI 2):V DQG
4?:?>141:3!<;!3F1!5<?6@!GF<HJ@!F?A1!4?d<6=3C!2?63=B=2?3=<:!5C!#P.N!%3!=G!<H6!
PRQH\µ!
x ´7KH 2::$ )XQG VKRXOG EH « WUDQVSDUHQW WR DOO PHPEHUV DQG WKH\
VKRXOGEHLQIRUPHGZKHUHWKHIXQGLVEHLQJXVHGµ!
x ´2::$VKRXOGEHWUDQVSDUHQWSDUWLFXODUO\ZLWKUHJDUGVWRLWVIXQGVµ!
x ´7KH RQO\ WLPH ZH VHH 2::$ LVZKHQ WK1C! O?:3! HG! 3<! 2?C! Q! F<O!?5<H3!
ZKHQZHQHHGWKHP"$ORWRIUHFRQVWUXFWLRQQHHGVWREHGRQHµ!
x ´7KH\DUHMXVWPDNLQJPRQH\RXWRIWKHSHRSOHE\FROOHFWLQJPHPEHUVKLS
;11G!5H3!3F1C!?61!:<3!A16C!F1J2;HJN!
x µ2QH WKLQJ , GR VXJJHVW WR 2::$ Q! 2J1?G1! 4?:?>1! 3F1! #../! ;H:@!
51B?HG1!3F=G!4<:1C!=G!?J4<G3!3?K1:!;6<4!3F1!5J<<@!<;!#P.G!?:@!3F1C!@=@!:<3!
dHG3!2=BK!3F1!4<:1C!;6<4!3F1!6<?@!G=@1!?:@!><!F<41!3<!3F1!"F=J=22=:1GN!*F1C!
VXIIHUHGDORWWREXLOGWKDWIXQGµ!
x ´%3! L#../M! @<1G:W3! O<6K! ?:@!GF<HJ@! 51!BF?:>1@! =441@=?31JCN! *F=G! =G! ?!
6<5516C!5C!3F1!><A16:41:3!OF<!B?JJ!3F14!TF16<1GTN!
!
.F1:! ?GK1@! =;! 3F1! #P.G! O161! =:! ;?A<6! <;! =:B61?G=:>! 3F1! ;H:@I! 4?:C! <;! 3F1! 98_!
61G2<:@1:3G! GH22<631@! 3F1! =@1?! 5H3! =:@=B?31@! 3F?3! 3F1! #P.G! GF<HJ@! :<3! 51! 3F1!
G<H6B1!<;!3F1!?@@=3=<:?J!;H:@GN!
!3"
x ´D?2?3!2?J?K=F=:!?:>!#../!;H:@GI!216<!@=!:?!4?>3??G!?:>!5?5?C?6?:!:>!
#P.N! L%3! =G! <K?C! 3<! =:B61?G1! 3F1! ;H:@! ?G! J<:>! ?G! #../! O=JJ! >13! =3! ;6<4!
=:A1G341:3G!?:@!:<3!5C!=:B61?G=:>!3F1!E0f7_!414516GF=2!;11NMN!
!
x µ#../! =G! ?! O1J;?61! <6>?:=U?3=<:! ?:@! :<3! ?! ;H:@! =:G3=3H3=<:N! %:G31?@! <;!
=:B61?G=:>!3F1!;H:@!3F1C!GF<HJ@!J<<K!?3!=:A1G341:3G!3<!=:B61?G1!3F1!;H:@!
5H3! :<3! 3<! 3?K1! =3! ;6<4! 3F1! #P.G! L5C! =:B61?G=:>! 3F1! 414516GF=2! ;11G!
B<JJ1B31@!;6<4!3F14MN!
!
!!!!2::$·V&RPPXQLFDWLRQZLWK2):V!
4XHVWLRQV RQ 2::$·V FRPPXQLFDWLRQ OLQHV
O=3F!#P.G!
)H4516! OF<!
VDLG ´<HVµ
LgM!
)H4516! OF<!
VDLG´1Rµ!
!
z ,<O!O<HJ@!C<H!J=K1!3<!B<44H:=B?31!C<H6!
GH>>1G3=<:G!3<!3F1!#../!V<?6@k!L:lb]^M!
x *F6<H>F!3F1!#../!O15G=31!
x *F6<H>F! C<H6! 61261G1:3?3=A1! 3<!
&<:>61GG!
x !/:<3F16!O?C!
!
!
`88!L^^N_9M!
9\b!L7\N8aM!
9]a!L7bN^9M!
!
!
!
Q!
!
!
z D<! C<H! 3F=:K! #P.G! GF<HJ@! F?A1! ?:C!
FRQWURO RYHU 2::$·V GHFLVLRQV WR DOWHU RU
3164=:?31!G16A=B1Gk!L:l`]]M!
!
!
``b!
La\N97M!
!
^9!
L98NaaM!
!
+1GHJ3G! !GF<O1@!3F?3! #P.G!261;16!3<! B<44H:=B?31! 3<! #../!3F6<H>F! =3G!O15G=31!
ZKLFK LV DYDLODEOH  KRXUV D GD\ 5HJDUGLQJ 2::$·V @1B=G=<:! 4?K=:>! 26<B1GGI!
a\g!<;!#P.!61G2<:@1:3G!=:@=B?31@!3F?3!#P.G!GF<HJ@!@1B=@1!OF=BF!G16A=B1G!GF<HJ@!
51!BF?:>1@!<6!3164=:?31@N!!
!2"
P%)D%)Z0!
7KHVXUYH\UHVXOWVUHIOHFWHGWKHQHHGWRUHIRUP2::$·VRSHUDWLRQVDQGVWUXFWXUH
?G! 3F1! 4?=:! ><A16:41:3?J! 1:3=3C! 61G2<:G=5J1! ;<6! 26<31B3=:>! ?:@! 26<4<3=:>! 3F1!
O1J;?61! ?:@! O1JJQ51=:>! <;! <A16G1?G! P=J=2=:<! O<6K16GN! *F1! #P.! 61G2<:@1:3G! ?61!
@14?:@=:>! G=42J16! ?:@! 1;;=B=1:3! 26<B1@H61G! ;<6! 3F14! 3<! ?A?=J! <;! #../! 51:1;=3G!
?:@! G16A=B1G! ?:@! 513316! =:;<64?3=<:! @=GG14=:?3=<:! <;! 3F1! ?>HQF\·V UROH DQG LWV
26<>6?4GN!*F1!#P.G!?61!?JG<!@14?:@=:>!?!BF?:>1!=:!3F1!B<42<G=3=<:!<;!3F1!V<?6@!
3F?3! O<HJ@! 4?K1! =3! 4<61! 61261G1:3?3=A1! <;! <A16G1?G! P=J=2=:<! O<6K16G! ?:@! OF=BF!
1R16B=G1G!=3G!;=@HB=?6C!61G2<:G=5=J=3C!=:!K112=:>!O=3F!3F1!4?:@?31!<;!#../N!!
/;WHU PRUH WKDQ  \HDUV VLQFH 2::$·V IRXQGLQJ D VLJQLILFDQW QXPEHU RI 2):
61G2<:@1:3G!O161! 1=3F16!H:?O?61!<6!4=G=:;<641@!?5<H3! 3F1!6<J1! ?:@!4?:@?31!<;!
3F1!?>1:BCN!*F=G!GF<OG!3F?3!#../!F?G!:<3!?@1SH?31JC!=:;<641@!3F1!#P.G!?:@!F?G!
:<3!H3=J=U1@!1;;1B3=A1!41?:G!<;!B<44H:=B?3=<:N!P=:@=:>G!=:!3F=G!G3H@C!?JG<!2<=:3!3<!
3F1!:11@!;<6!#../!3<!B61?31!?!41BF?:=G4!OF=BF!O<HJ@!;?B=J=3?31!B<44H:=B?3=<:G!
?:@!B<:GHJ3?3=<:!O=3F!#P.0!<:!?JJ!?G21B3G!<;!=3G!<216?3=<:GN!!
7KH 2::$ %RDUG RI 7UXVWHHV· GHFLVLRQ RQ WKH PHPEHUVKLS IHH A=<J?31@! 3F1!
DJHQF\·VPDQGDWH7KHUHLVDOVRDQDEVHQFHRIWUDQVSDUHQF\LQLWVGHFLVLRQPDNLQJ
26<B1GGI!B<42<G=3=<:I!?:@!@=G5H6G141:3!<;!;H:@GN!*F1!5H61?HB6?3=B!26<B1@H61G!=:!
?22JC=:>!;<6!414516GF=2I!?A?=J=:>!<;!3F1!51:1;=3GI!?:@!<53?=:=:>!=:;<64?3=<:!61J?31@!
3<!<A16G1?G!B<:36?B3!O<6K!:11@!3<!51!BF?:>1@N!!!
+1;<64!<;!#../!=G!?!26=<6=3C!B<:B16:!<;!#P.G!51B?HG1!=3!=G!3F1!><A16:41:3!?>1:BC!
3F?3!O?G!4?:@?31@!3<!26<4<31!?:@!26<31B3!3F1!O1J;?61!?:@!O1JJQ51=:>!<;!<A16G1?G!
P=J=2=:<!O<6K16GN!#P.GI!&(/I!?:@!=3G!2?63:16G!O=JJ!B<:3=:H1!3<!?@A<B?31!;<6!#../!
3<!;HJ;=JJ!=3G!4?:@?31N!
P%)D%)Z!*,-!+%Z,*!V/$/)&-X!!
"+#m%D%)Z!0-+m%&-0!/)D!/**/%)%)Z!PE)D!0E0*/%)/V%$%*'!
036=K=:>!3F1!6=>F3!5?J?:B1!513O11:!26<A=@=:>!3=41JC!?:@!?@1SH?31!G16A=B1G!3<!#P.G!
?:@!3F1=6! ;?4=J=1GI!?:@! ?BF=1A=QJ IXQG VWDELOLW\LV WKH FRUHRI2::$·VRSHUDWLRQV
,<O1A16I! J<<K=:>! ?3! 3F1! GH6A1C! 61GHJ3G! 61A1?J! 3F?3! 3F1! 5?J?:B1! =G! ;?6! ;6<4! 51=:>!
?BF=1A1@N!!!
%3! =G! =4216?3=A1! 3F?3! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! ><A16:41:3! 36HJC! ;HJ;=JJ! #../WG! 2H62<G1I! ?:@!
26<31B3!3F1! #P.G! ?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!! E:;<63H:?31JCI! #../!F?G! ;?JJ1:!GF<63!<;!=3G!
4?:@?31! @H1! 3<! ?! B<45=:?3=<:! <;! B<:;HG=<:! ?5<H3! =3G! G21B=;=B! 2<O16G! ?:@!
61G2<:G=5=J=3=1G!?:@!26<5J14G!GCG314=B!3<!3F1!<6>?:=U?3=<:!?G!=3!;H:B3=<:G!:<ON!
#6>?:=U?3=<:?JX!!&<:;HG=<:!?5<H3!=3G!G21B=;=B!2<O16G!?:@!61G2<:G=5=J=3=1G!
#../! O?G! B61?31@! 3F6<H>F! ?!G16=1G! <;! J?OG! 3F?3! J1;3! G<41! B6HB=?J! @13?=JG!<;! 3F1!
<6>?:=U?3=<:!H:@1;=:1@N!(?:C! SH1G3=<:G!614?=:! 3<!51!61G<JA1@!?5<H3! #../I! ?:@!
H:3=J! 3F1C! ?61I! 3F1! <6>?:=U?3=<:! O=JJ! :<3! 51! ?5J1! 3<! G16A1! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;! #P.G!
1;;1B3=A1JCN!!&H661:3JCI!#../!=G!<216?3=:>!=:!3F1!>61C!?61?!<;!3F=G!B<:;HG=<:I!?:@!=G!
FH63=:>! #P.GI! 6?3F16! 3F?:! 26<31B3=:>! 3F14I! 5C! BF?6>=:>! ;11G! O=3F<H3! 26<A=@=:>!
51:1;=3GN!*F1!SH1G3=<:G!?5<H3!#../!3F?3!:11@!3<!51!61G<JA1@!=441@=?31JC!?61X!
!4"
x %G!#../!?!Z<A16:41:3!?>1:BCI!<6!:<3k!!
0=:B1!9\a8I!#../!=G!?:!=:@121:@1:3!;=:?:B=?J!?>1:BC!3F?3!4?:?>1G!3F1!O1J;?61!
;H:@! <;! <A16G1?G! O<6K16G! ?:@! 26<A=@1! G16A=B1G! 3<! =3G! B<:36=5H3=:>! 414516G! J=K1!
J<?:G! ?:@! =:GH6?:B1GN! ! %3! =G! 1:3=61JC! G1J;Q;H:@1@! 3F6<H>F! 3F1! B<:36=5H3=<:G! <;! =3G!
414516G! ?:@! 61B1=A1G! :<! ?JJ<B?3=<:! ;6<4! 3F1! :?3=<:?J! ><A16:41:3I! ! *FHGI! =3! =G!
H:@1B=@1@!=;!#../!=G!?!><A16:41:3!?>1:BC!<6!?!26=A?31!<6>?:=U?3=<:N!%;!#../!=G!
not!?!><A16:41:3!<6>?:=U?3=<:I!3F1:!3F1!"F=J=22=:1G!><A16:41:3!=G!B<:G3=3H3=<:?JJC!
<5J=>1@!3<!1G3?5J=GF!?!><A16:41:3?J!<6>?:=U?3=<:!3<!26<31B3!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!=3G!#P.GN!
%;!#../!is!?!><A16:41:3!<6>?:=U?3=<:I!3F1:!3F1!"F=J=22=:1!><A16:41:3!4HG3!51>=:!
3<! ;HJ;=JJ! =3G! 61G2<:G=5=J=3C! ?:@! ;H:@! 3F1! #../! ?@4=:=G36?3=<:N! ! %;! :<3I! 3F1:! 3F1!
JRYHUQPHQW·VUH261G1:3?3=<:!=:!3F1!V<?6@!<;!*6HG311G!=G!@1;=:=31JC!=:!SH1G3=<:N!!!*<!
?!J?6>16!1R31:3I!OF?3!=G!51=:>!SH1G3=<:1@!F161!=G!3F1!G=:B16=3C!<;!3F1!><A16:41:3!3<!
=42J141:3! ?G! 4?:@?31@! =:! +/G! a8^7! ?:@! 98877! 3<! 26<4<31! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;!
4=>6?:3!O<6K16G!?:@!2J?B1!3F1=6!26<31B3=<:!?5<A1!1JG1N!
x %G! #../! ?:! =:GH6?:B1! GBF141I! ?! 26<31B3=<:! ?>1:BCI! ?! J<?:! 5?:KI! <6!
G<B=?J!G1BH6=3Ck!!
#../! <;;16G! ?! A?6=13C! <;! 4=R1@! 51:1;=3G! ?:@! G16A=B1GI! OF=BF! =42JC! B<:36?@=B3<6C!
@1;=:=3=<:G!<;!3F1!<6>?:=U?3=<:N!/G!3F1!#../!;H:@!=G!J=4=31@I!3F1G1!A?6=<HG!G16A=B1G!
B<42131! ;<6! 3F1! ;=:=31! 61G<H6B1GI! G<! 3F?3! HJ3=4?31JC! :<! #P.! B?:! ?A?=J! <;! ?:C! <;!
3F14N! *F1! 4?3316! <;! 1R2163=G1! <:! 3F1! A?6=<HG! 26<>6?4G! ?JG<! B<41! =:3<! 2J?CN! .1!
61414516!3<<!O1JJ!3F?3!3F1!6?3=<:?J1!;<6!3F1!GH@@1:!@1B=G=<:!3<!36?:G;16!3F1!#../!
(1@=B?61! ;6<4! #../!3<! "F=JF1?J3F! O?G!51B?HG1! <;! #../WG!:<:Q1R2163=G1! =:!3F1!
?@4=:=G36?3=<:! ?:@! 4?:?>141:3! <;! F1?J3FQ41@=B?J! 51:1;=3G! ;<6! #P.G! ?:@! 3F1=6!
;?4=J=1GN! -SH?JJC! =42<63?:3! =G! 1:GH6=:>! 3F?3! 3F1! #../! O1J;?61! 26<>6?4G! ?:@!
G16A=B1G!?61!?BB1GG1@!1;;1B3=A1JC!5C!3F1!G1B3<6!5C!26<A=@=:>!BJ1?6!>H=@1J=:1G!?:@!?:!
1;;1B3=A1!41BF?:=G4!;<6!3F1=6!?A?=J41:3N!!!!
.F=J1! ?JJ!3F1! G16A=B1G!?:@! 51:1;=3G!;<6! #P.G! ?:@!3F1=6! ;?4=J=1G!4?K1! G1:G1I! 3F=G!
KDVUDLVHGXQFHUWDLQWLHVRQ2::$·VFDSDFLW\WRIXQGZHOIDUHVHUYLFHVDQGP?:?>1!
LWV PHPEHUV· IXQGV ²! D IXQGDPHQWDO HOHPHQW RI 2::$·V OHJLWLPDF\ DQG IXUWKHU
GH6A=A?JN!
x .F<!4HG3!2?C!3F1!#../!;11k!!
"61;16?5JCI!3F1!142J<C16!?:@[<6!?>1:BC!2?CG!3F1!414516GF=2!;11N!!,<O1A16I!=3!=G!?!
O1JJQK:<O:!;?B3!3F?3!3F=G!=G!2?GG1@!<:!3<!4=>6?:3!O<6K16GN!!$1>?JJCI!3F1!O<6K16!4HG3!
:1A16!51!BF?6>1@!3F1!#../!;11N!,<O1A16I!#../!;?=J1@!3<!2H3!=:!2J?B1!?:!1;;1B3=A1!
41BF?:=G4! ;<6! 3F1!=42J141:3?3=<:! <;! 3F=G!2<J=BCN! %:! 26?B3=B1I! ?3! J1?G3! 4<61! 3F?:!
_8g!<;!3F1!3<3?J!?::H?J!@12J<C41:3!<;!"#-/!OF<!B<426=G1@!3F1!61F=61@!O<6K16G!<6!
´balik manggagawaµ ZKRVH ZRUN FRQWUDFWV KDYH EHHQ H[WHQGHG RQQG=31I! 2?C! 3F1!
#../!;11!3F14G1JA1G!H2<:!26<B1GG=:>!<;!3F1=6!@<BH41:3G!?3!3F1!"#-/N!!
P<6!;=6G3!3=41!4=>6?:3!O<6K16GI!<:! 3F1!<3F16!F?:@I! 3F1=6!?>1:B=1G!?61!GH22<G1@!3<!
GF<HJ@16! 3F1! #../! ;11N! ,<O1A16I! 3F161! ?61! G3=JJ! 4?:C! ?BB<H:3G! 5C! #P.G!
3F14G1JA1GI!BJ?=4=:>!3F?3!3F1!;11!2?=@!;<6!5C!3F1!?>1:BC!?61!J?316!<:!B<JJ1B31@!5?BK!
!7"
;6<4!3F1!#P.G!3F14G1JA1GN!/G!;<6!#P.G!=:! =661>HJ?6!G3?3HG!?56<?@I!#../!G=42JC!
@<1G!:<3!F?A1!?:C!41BF?:=G4!=:!2J?B1!3<!1:GH61!3F1!B<JJ1B3=<:!<;!3F1!#../!;11N!!
*F=G!=:1SH=3?5J1!26?B3=B1!;?JJG!F1?A=1G3!<:!3F<G1!#P.G!OF<!F?A1!3F1!J1?G3!J1A16?>1!
O=3F!3F1=6!142J<C16G!?:@!:11@!3F1!26<31B3=<:!<;!#../!3F1!4<G3N!0=:B1!G<41!#P.G!
?61!;<6B1@!3<!2?C!1A16C!3=41!3F1C!B<41!F<41!3<!A=G=3!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GI!G<41!#P.G!2?C!
FH:@61@G!<;!@<JJ?6G!=:!#../!;11GI!OF=J1!<3F16G!2?C!:<3F=:>N!!
.<HJ@! =3! 51! 513316! 3<! 36C! 3<! 1:;<6B1! 3F1! J?OI! ?:@! B<421J! 3F1! 142J<C16G! 3<! 2?C!
@1G2=31!3F1!26?B3=B?J!@=;;=BHJ3=1Gk!#6!=G!=3!513316!3<!BF?:>1!3F1!J?OI!?:@!3<!?@4=3!3F?3!
=:!26?B3=B1!#P.G!2?C!3F1!;11I!?:@!BF?6>1!1?BF!#P.!GCG314?3=B?JJC!?:@!1SH=3?5JCk!!
0<41!4=>6?:3!<6>?:=U?3=<:G!?61!1A1:!SH1G3=<:=:>!3F1!?H3F<6=3C!<;!#../!3<!61SH=61!
GHBF!2?C41:3N!
x %G!=3!?!414516GF=2!<6>?:=U?3=<:k!
VC!A=63H1!<;!#../!V<?6@!+1G<JH3=<:!8`aI!<3F16O=G1!K:<O:!?G!3F1!#../!#4:=5HG!
"<J=BCI! ?@<231@! =:! 012314516! 788`I! 3F1! #../! V<?6@!36?:G;<641@! #../!=:3<! ?!
414516GF=2Q5?G1@! <6>?:=U?3=<:N! *F1! ! !TB<:36=5H3=<:! ;11T! 51B?41! ?! T414516GF=2!
;11T!=:!3F1!#4:=5HG!"<J=B=1GI!?:@!J=4=31@!3F1!#../!G16A=B1G!3<!T#../!414516GT!
=:!?:!?331423!3<!4?=:3?=:!;H:@!A=?5=J=3CN!%3!=G!=JJ1>?J!;<6!3F1!"F=J=22=:1G!><A16:41:3!
3<!J=4=3!=3G!26<31B3=<:!<;!=3G!#P.G!<:JC!3<!T#../!414516GNT!!
,<O1A16I! >=A1:! 3F?3! G<41! #P.G! 2?C! ;<6! #../I! ?:@! <3F16G! @<! :<3I! F<O! GF<HJ@!
#../! @=G5H6G1! =3G! G16A=B1G! ?:@! 51:1;=3G! 4<G3! 1SH=3?5JC! ?:@! 1;;=B=1:3JC! OF=J1!
4?=:3?=:=:>! ;H:@! A=?5=J=3Ck! %;! #../! =G! ?! 414516GF=2! <6>?:=U?3=<:I! F<O! O=JJ! 3F1!
"F=J=22=:1!><A16:41:3!26<31B3!3F1!614?=:=:>I!:<:QT#../!414516T!#P.Gk!
D1G2=31!3F1!4?:@?3<6C!414516GF=2!61SH=6141:3I!=3!=G!:<3!?!614<31!2<GG=5=J=3C!>=A1:!
3F1! J?6>1! :H4516! <;! #P.GI! 3F?3! 4?:C! #P.G! OF<! 1R31:@1@! 3F1=6! B<:36?B3G! OF=J1!
<A16G1?G!5H3!@=@!:<3!61:1O!3F1=6!#../!414516GF=2N!
x ,<O!@<1G!#../!61J?31!3<!<3F16!#P.!?>1:B=1Gk!
/J3F<H>F!#../!=G!@1;=:1@!?G!?:!?33?BF1@!?>1:BC!<;!3F1!D12?6341:3!<;!$?5<6!?:@!
-42J<C41:3! LD#$-MI! =3! 614?=:G! H:B163?=:! F<O! #../! =G! GH22<G1@! 3<! B<<216?31!
O=3F! <3F16! #P.Q<6=1:3?31@! ?>1:B=1GN! 0<41! <;! #../WG! G16A=B1G! ?61! 61@H:@?:3I!
G<41! O<HJ@! 51! 513316! 4?:?>1@! 5C! ?! @=;;161:3! ?>1:BCI! ?:@! G<41! :1B1GG?6C!
G16A=B1G!?61!J1;3!H:413!5C!?:C!?>1:BCN!!
P<6!1R?42J1I!#../!<;;16G!612?36=?3=<:!G16A=B1G!?3!3F1!G?41!3=41!3F?3!#../!3?K1G!
BF?6>1! <;!3F1! -416>1:BC! +12?36=?3=<:! PH:@! L-+PMN! /@@=3=<:?JJCI! OF=J1!#../! 4?C!
G3=JJ! 26<A=@1! F1?J3F! ?:@! 41@=B?J! 51:1;=3GI! =:! ?B3H?J=3C! 3F1C! 61J=:SH=GF1@! 3F=G!
61G2<:G=5=J=3C! 3<! "F=J,1?J3FI! ?BK:<OJ1@>=:>! "F=J,1?J3FWG! >61?316! 1R216=1:B1! ?:@!
B<42131:B1N!#../!4HG3!1G3?5J=GF!?!BJ1?6!61J?3=<:GF=2!O=3F!#E(./!L#;;=B1!<;!3F1!
E:@16G1B613?6C!;<6!(=>6?:3! .<6K16G!/;;?=6GM!OF=BF! =G! J=K1O=G1!4?:@?31@!5C!J?O! 3<!
3?K1!B?61!<;!#P.GI!"F=J,1?J3FI!000!L0<B=?J!01BH6=3C!0CG314MI!"#-/I!D#$-I!?:@!J<?:!
<;;16=:>!V?:KGI!G<!3F?3!?JJ!3F1!#P.GW!B6HB=?J!:11@G!?61!G16A1@I!OF=J1!:<!1;;<63G!?61!
#6"
@H2J=B?31@N!
,QUHDOLW\2::$·VSDUWQHUVKLSVZLWKRWKHUDJHQFLHVFRPHZLWKULVNV7KLVLQFOXGHV
2<<6! B<<6@=:?3=<:! <:! 1416>1:BC! =GGH1G! ?:@! 4=GH:@16G3?:@=:>G! ?5<H3!
H[SHFWDWLRQV 7KXV HYHQ WKH XVH RI 2::$·V IXQGV DV D ORDQ RI WKH QDWLRQDO
><A16:41:3! 3<! ;H:@! 1416>1:BC! 612?36=?3=<:[1A?BH?3=<:I! GF<HJ@! 51! 1:3161@! O=3F!
H34<G3!B?H3=<:N!!#3F16O=G1I!3F=G!?>61141:3!PD\GHSOHWHWKHDJHQF\·VIXQGEDODQFH
OF=BF!=G!261B?6=<HG!3<!;=:?:B=?J!G3?5=J=3CN!
x .F<!<O:G!3F1!*6HG3!PH:@k!
$ VLJQLILFDQW PDMRULW\ RI 2::$·V LQYHVWPHQW SRUWIROLR KDG EHHQ HQWHUHG LQWR DQ
%:A1G341:3! (?:?>141:3!/>61141:3! O=3F! 3F1! $?:@! V?:K! <;! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1G! L$V"M!
?:@! 3F1! D1A1J<241:3! V?:K! <;! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1G! LDV"MN! ! /G! =:A1G341:3! 4?:?>16GI!
5<3F!5?:KG!?61!?H3F<6=U1@!3<!=:A1G3[61=:A1G3!;H:@G!=:!><A16:41:3!G1BH6=3=1GN!!!
%3! =G! H:B163?=:! OF<! <O:G! 3F1! #../! ;H:@I! :<O! ?4<H:3=:>! 3<! G<41! "99N]V!
@12<G=31@!=:!3F1!DV"!?:@!$V"N!)<5<@C!K:<OG!=;!=3!51J<:>G!3<!3F1!><A16:41:3!<6!3<!
3F1! #P.GN! %;! #../! O161! 3<! 51! @=GG<JA1@I! O<HJ@! 3F1! 4<:1C! ><! 3<! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1!
><A16:41:3!<6!5?BK!3<!3F1!#P.Gk!!
x ,<O!GF<HJ@!3F1!4<:1C!51!HG1@k!
%3! =G! H:B163?=:! =;! ?:C! >H=@1J=:1G! J=4=3! 3F1! HG1! <;! #../! ;H:@GN! &H661:3JCI! a8g! <;!
#../WG! 5H@>13! GH22<63G! =3G! <O:! ?@4=:=G36?3=<:N! /@@=3=<:?JJCI! #../! ;H:@G! ?61!
URXWLQHO\XVHGIRURXWVLGHSXUSRVHVDQG´HPHUJHQF\µVLWXDWLRQV,I2::$IXQGVDUH
<:JC!3<!51!HG1@!;<6!#../!G16A=B1GI!3F1C!4HG3! 51!1R2J=B=3JC!26<31B31@!=:! O6=3=:>!3<!
261A1:3!=3G!4=GHG1N!
*6?:G2?61:BC!=:!3F1!4?:?>141:3!?:@!?BB<H:3=:>!<;!3F1!O1J;?61!;H:@!=G!?!4HG3!;<6!
#../! G=:B1! =3G! ;H:@G! ?61! ;6<4! 3F1! 414516G! 3F14G1JA1GN! ! #216?3=<:?J!
WUDQVSDUHQF\LVPRUHWKDQUHTXLUHGHVSHFLDOO\ZLWKWKHJRYHUQPHQW·V &RPPLVVLRQ
<:! /H@=3! 612<63! ;6<4! 9\\\! 3<! 788_! G3?3=:>! 3F?3! 3F161! ?61! 4=JJ=<:G! <;! 21G<G! =:!
XQOLTXLGDWHGFDVKDGYDQFHVDQGLQ´GRXEWIXODFFRXQWVµ!
,QFOXGHGLQ WKLV ´GRXEWIXO DFFRXQWµ ZDV WKH6PRNH\ 0RXQWDLQ3URMHFW DKRXVLQJ
26<>6?4!;<6!3F1!H65?:!2<<6N!!*F1!788_!/H@=3!+12<63!H:@16GB<61@!3F?3!3F1!61B<A16C!
RIWKH30LQYHVWPHQWLQWKHSURMHFWLV´XQFHUWDLQµ!
#216?3=<:?JX!!"6<5J14G!GCG314=B!3<!3F1!<6>?:=U?3=<:!
#../!=G!6=;1!O=3F!26<5J14G!=:!=3G!BH661:3!<6>?:=U?3=<:N!0=:B1!=3!F?G!511:!<216?3=:>!
=:! 3F1! >6?C! ?61?! <;! B<:;HG=<:I! 4?:C! GCG314=B! 26<5J14G! F?A1! >6<O:! =:3<! 3F1!
<6>?:=U?3=<:N!
x V1:1;=3G!?:@!016A=B1GX!56<K1:!26<4=G1G!
#../! 26<4=G1G! ?:! ?G3<H:@=:>! ?66?C! <;! 51:1;=3G! ?:@! G16A=B1GI! ;6<4! J<?:GI! 3<!
#!"
612?36=?3=<:I!?:@!A?6=<HG!=:GH6?:B1GN!!#../I!F<O1A16I!61B1=A1G!:<!4<:1C!;6<4!3F1!
"F=J=22=:1!><A16:41:3I!?:@!61J=1G!1:3=61JC!<:!3F1!:<4=:?J!E0f7_!T414516GF=2!;11T!
B<JJ1B31@!1A16C!3O<!C1?6GI!?3!4<G3N!!
%:! B<42?6=G<:I! 000! BF?6>1G! <:!3F1! ?A16?>1!! "F2^I888[! C1?6! ;6<4! 3F1!142J<C11!
LO=3F=:! 3F1! "98I888! 4<:3FJC! G?J?6C! 56?BK13MN! *FHGI! =3! =G! ;=GB?JJC! =42<GG=5J1! ;<6!
#../! 3<! <;;16! 3F1! ;HJJ! ?66?C! <;! G16A=B1G! =3! ?@A163=G1G! ;<6! GHBF! ?! G4?JJ! ;11N!
/@@=3=<:?JJCI! #../! <;;16G! :1O! J<?:G! 1A16C! C1?6I! 3F<H>F! =3! F?G! :<! ;H:B3=<:?J!
26<B1@H61G! 3<! 1:;<6B1! 612?C41:3! <;! J<?:GN! 0=:B1! #../! =G! B<:G3?:3JC! ?;6?=@! <;!
5?:K6H23=:>! 3F1! ;H:@I! 3F1C! 6<H3=:1JC! GHG21:@! 51:1;=3G! ?:@! G16A=B1G! <6! =:G3=3H31!
:H416<HG!26<B1@H6?J!?:@!5H61?HB6?3=B!<5G3?BJ1G!3<!261A1:3!#P.G!;6<4!?BB1GG=:>!
3F1!G16A=B1GN!!
/G!41:3=<:1@!1?6J=16I!3F1!BH661:3!26<B1@H61G!;<6!?A?=J41:3!<;!51:1;=3G!?:@!G16A=B1G!
261G1:3! RYHUZKHOPLQJ GLIILFXOWLHV IRU PRVW 2):V ZKR VHHN 2::$·V DVVLVWDQFH
7KXV LW QRW XQXVXDO IRU 2):V ZKR KDYH WULHG WR DFFHVV 2::$·V VHUYLFHV UHSRUW
WKDW´2::$H[LVWVRQSDSHURQO\µ!
x 01A161!J?BK!<;!=:;<64?3=<:!?4<:>!#P.G!!
*<!4<G3!#P.GI!#../!=G!?GG<B=?31@!O=3F!3F1!E0f7_!;11!3F1C!F?A1!3<!2?C!<6!3F1C!
O=JJ!:<3!51!=GGH1@!?:!<A16G1?G!142J<C41:3!B163=;=B?31N!*F1C!?JG<!K:<O!3F?3!#../!
=G!3F1! ?>1:BC!3<! ><!3<! =;!?:@! OF1:!3F1C! ?61!=:! @=G361GGN!VH3!F<O! 1R?B3JC!3F1C!B?:!
?BB1GG! 3F1! G16A=B1G! <;! #../! =G! :<3! A16C! BJ1?6! 3<! 4?:C! <;! 3F14N! #P.G! 612<631@!
=>:<6?:B1!?5<H3!4?d<6!#../!2<J=B=1GI!61SH=6141:3GI!51:1;=3GI!?:@!G16A=B1GN!*F161!
=G!:<!BJ1?6!41BF?:=G4!;<6!#../!3<!O=@1JC!61?BF!<H3!?:@!@=GG14=:?31!=:;<64?3=<:!
3<!#P.GN!!
x *6?:G2?61:BC!
D1G2=31!&<:G3=3H3=<:?J!61SH=6141:3G!;<6!36?:G2?61:BCI!:1=3F16!3F1!#../!;H:@G!:<6!
3F1! V<?6@! ?22<=:341:3G! ?61! B<:@HB31@! O=3F! ?@1SH?31! 36?:G2?61:BCN! *F1!
26<4HJ>?3=<:!<;!3F1!#../!#4:=5HG!"<J=B=1G!5C!3F1!#../!V<?6@!=:!788`!O=3F<H3!
B<:GHJ3?3=<:! OF?3G<1A16! O=3F! 3F1!4=>6?:3G!?:@!3F1! 4=>6?:3! >6<H2G!O?G!?! B?G1!=:!
2<=:3!<;!G1A161!J?BK!<;!36?:G2?61:BC!<;!#../N!!!
&163?=:JCI! <:1! ?61?! 3F?3! :11@G! 3<! 51! 36?:G2?61:3! =G! 3F1! 26<B1GG! ;<6! 2<J=BC! ?:@!
@1B=G=<:!4?K=:>!<;!3F1!V<?6@N!!(=:H31G!<;!3F1!5<?6@!4113=:>G!?61!:<3!?BB1GG=5J1!3<!
=3G! 414516G!:<6! ! =G!=3! ?A?=J?5J1! =:! 3F1! O15G=31N! ! *FHGI! 3F161! =G! ?JO?CG! ?!BJ<H@! <;!
GRXEW KDQJLQJ RYHU WKH %RDUG·V GHFLVLRQ :KHWKHU WKHUH LV VXEVWDQFH WR WKHVH
?JJ1>?3=<:G!=G!@=;;=BHJ3!3<!@13164=:1!@H1!3<!3F1!J?BK!<;!36?:G2?61:BC!=:!3F1!@1B=G=<:!
4?K=:>!26<B1GGN!
x /BB<H:3?5=J=3C!
E:@16!3F1!BH661:3!#4:=5HG!"<J=B=1GI!?:!#../!V<?6@!414516!B?:!1J1B3!?!26<RC!3<!
;HJ;=JJ! F=G[F16! #../! @H3=1GN! *F=G! B61?31G! ?! GCG314! =:! OF=BF! ?! V<?6@! 414516! =G!
:1=3F16!?BB<H:3?5J1!;<6!?331:@?:B1!:<6!;<6!V<?6@!@1B=G=<:GN!!!
##"
-RB123! ;<6! 3F<G1! 61261G1:3=:>! 3F1! A?6=<HG! ><A16:41:3! ?>1:B=1G! OF<G1!
61261G1:3?3=<:! =G! ?H3<4?3=B! 5C! A=63H1! <;! 3F1=6! 2<G=3=<:I! 3F1! "61G=@1:3! ?22<=:3G! ?JJ!
414516G! <;! 3F1! V<?6@! <;! *6HG311GN! ! *F=G! 4?C! G114! 3<! 51! 3F1! 4<G3! 26?B3=B?J!
?66?:>141:3! >=A1:! 3F1!B<42J1R! 26<B1GG!<;! B<:GHJ3=:>! #../!414516G! G261?@! =:!
?J4<G3! 788! B<H:36=1GN! ! '13I! 3F1! SH1G3=<:! 614?=:GX! ! ?61! 3F1C! ?BB<H:3?5J1! 3<! 3F1!
"61G=@1:3! OF<! ?22<=:31@! 3F14! <6! O=JJ! 3F1C! 36HJC! 61261G1:3! 3F1! =:3161G3G! <;! 3F1=6!
;1JJ<O!4=>6?:3!O<6K16!
x +1261G1:3?3=<:!
/J3F<H>F! #../! =G! @1@=B?31@! 3<! #P.! O1J;?61I! #P.G! 4?K1! H2! <:JC! 9]g! <;! 3F1!
V<?6@N!/:!<A16OF1J4=:>!4?d<6=3C!<;!V<?6@!414516G!?61!:<3!#../!414516GI!5H3!
?61! 61261G1:3?3=A1G! ;6<4! 3F1! ><A16:41:3! G1B3<6N! ! *F1! V<?6@! 414516! ;6<4! 3F1!
O<41:WG! G1B3<6I! ;H63F164<61I! =G! :<3! 61SH=61@! 3<! 51! ?! ;14?J1! #P.N! *F1! G1J1B3=<:!
26<B1GG!=G!1SH?JJC!:<3!36?:G2?61:3N!!!
/G=@1! ;6<4! =:B61?G=:>! 3F1! :H4516! <;!4=>6?:3! O<6K16G! =:! 3F1!V<?6@I! ! =3! =G! dHG3! ?G!
=42<63?:3! ;<6! #../! 3<! B61?31! ?:@! @1A1J<2! 41BF?:=G4G! 3F?3! ! O<HJ@! ?JJ<O! ;<6!
61>HJ?6!;11@5?BK!?:@!B<:GHJ3?3=<:!O=3F!=3G!414516GN!!*F1!61261G1:3?3=<:!<;!#P.G!
O=JJ!?JO?CG!51!J=4=31@!=;!GHBF!26<B1GG!O=JJ!:<3!51!=:G3=3H3=<:?J=U1@N!
x &<:GHJ3?3=<:!
*F1! #../! V<?6@! @<1G! :<3! B<:GHJ3! #P.G! <6! #P.! )Z#G! 51;<61! 4?K=:>! 4?d<6!
@1B=G=<:G! GHBF! ?G! GHG21:@=:>! <6! 3164=:?3=:>! 51:1;=3G! <6! G16A=B1GI! <6! ?22<=:3=:>!
:1O!V<?6@!414516GN!/>?=:I!?!B?G1!=:!2<=:3!=G!3F1!#../!#4:=5HG!"<J=B=1GN!/:<3F16!
1R?42J1!=G!3F1!36?:G;16!<;!#../!(1@=B?61!3<!"F=JF1?J3FN!!
*F=G! 261@=B?41:3! =G! ?>>6?A?31@! 5C! 3F1! ;?B3! 3F?3! #../! @<1G! :<3! 2H5J=GF! <6!
@=GG14=:?31!3F1!@1B=G=<:!?:@[<6!61G<JH3=<:!<;!3F1!V<?6@N!
x $=4=3G!<:!?H3F<6=3C!<;!V<?6@!?61!:<3!<51C1@!!
/J3F<H>F!3F1!V<?6@!=G!<:JC!J1>?JJC!?H3F<6=U1@!3<!;<64HJ?31!?:@!=42J141:3!41?GH61G!
?:@! 26<>6?4G! 3<! ?33?=:! 3F1! ;H:@GW! <5d1B3=A1G! ?:@! 2H62<G1GI! =N1N! 3<! 26<A=@1! G<B=?J!
?:@!O1J;?61!G16A=B1G!3<!#P.GI!3F1!V<?6@!F?G!?GGH41@!>61?316!2<O16!5C!H:=J?316?JJC!
26<4HJ>?3=:>!3F1!#4:=5HG!"<J=B=1GI!O=3F<H3!?:C!61>?6@!3<!3F1=6!@=61!B<:G1SH1:B1G!
3<!3F1!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!
*F1!BH661:3!G13QH2!26<A=@1G!3F1!V<?6@!O=3F!1:<H>F!1J5<O!6<<4!3<!B6?;3!2<J=B=1G!?:@!
=42J141:3! 26<>6?4G! 3F?3! O<HJ@! 61G2<:@! 3<! #P.G! ! :11@! 1G21B=?JJC! =:! B6=G=G!
G=3H?3=<:GI!5H3!?3!3F1!G?41!3=41I!3F=G!?JG<!>=A1G!2164=GG=<:!3<!3F1!V<?6@!3<!1R16B=G1!
B<4261F1:G=A1!?:@!H:61>HJ?31@!?H3F<6=3CN!
*,-!(E&,Q)--D-D!+-P#+(0!%)!#../!
#../!O?G!B61?31@!;<6!3F1!A?JH?5J1!2H62<G1!<;!26<31B3=:>!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!!
/:@! ?G! O<6K=:>! <A16G1?G! 614?=:G! ?! O<6K?5J1! <23=<:! @1G2=31! =3G! @?:>16G! ?:@!
#$"
J=4=3?3=<:GI! 3F1! ><A16:41:3! F?G! 3<! =:G3=3H3=<:?J=U1! ?:@! G361:>3F1:! =3G! GH22<63! 3<!
#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!!#../!4?C!F?A1!;?JJ1:!GF<63!=:!3164G!<;!=42J141:3=:>!=3G!
4?:@?31!C13!=3!614?=:G!?G!3F1!4?=:!?>1:BC!;<6!26<31B3=:>!P=J=2=:<G!O<6K=:>!?56<?@!
@H1!3<!=3G!J?6>1!GB<21!<;!3?GKG!?:@!61G2<:G=5=J=3=1G!><=:>!51C<:@!J1>?J!?GG=G3?:B1N!
*F1!4<G3!B6HB=?J!G312!=:!61;<64=:>!#../!=G!1:?B3=:>!=3G!<O:!BF?6316N!!.F?3!=3!F?G!
=:!2J?B1! =G! 3F1!#../!#4:=5HG!"<J=B=1G! L#"M! 26<4HJ>?31@!5C!3F1!#../!V<?6@!<;!
*6HG311G!<:!012314516!9\I!788`N!*F1!#"!=:36<@HB1@!?!G16=1G!<;!4?d<6!BF?:>1G!=:!
3F1! <216?3=<:G! <;! 3F1! #../I! 2?63=BHJ?6JC! =:! 3F1! ?A?=J41:3! <;! =3G! 26<>6?4G! ?:@!
G16A=B1GN!!
*F1G1! BF?:>1GI! =:!1;;1B3I! ?41:@1@! ?!4?d<6! J?O! 26<A=G=<:! OF=BF! ?GG163G! 3F?3!3F1!
#../!B<:36=5H3=<:G!4HG3!:<3!=:!?:C!O?C!51!B<JJ1B31@!;6<4!3F1!4=>6?:3!O<6K16N!*F1!
#"! ?JG<! 4?@1! #../! ?! 414516GF=2Q5?G1@! ><A16:41:3! ?>1:BCN! *F1! B?G1! O?G!
56<H>F3!3<!3F1!B<H63G!5H3!3<!@?31I!?;316!4<61!3F?:!;=A1!C1?6GI!:<!@1B=G=<:!F?G!511:!
61:@161@N! ,1:B1I! =3! =G! H6>1:3! ?:@! :1B1GG?6C! 3F?3! &<:>61GG! 1:?B3G! ?! J1>=GJ?3=A1!
BF?6316!;<6!#../!3F?3!O=JJ!@1;=:1!=3G!2H62<G1GI!B<42<G=3=<:I!4?:?>141:3!;H:@=:>I!
26<>6?4G!?:@!G16A=B1GN!
0?J=1:3!P1?3H61G!<;!3F1!"6<2<G1@!#../!&F?6316!
&F?2316!%!!
0-&N!7N!D1BJ?6?3=<:!<;!"<J=BCN!%3!=G!3F1!2<J=BC!<;!3F1!03?31!3<!?;;<6@!;HJJ!26<31B3=<:!3<!
J?5<6I! J<B?J! ?:@! <A16G1?GI! <6>?:=U1@! ?:@! H:<6>?:=U1@I! ?:@! 26<4<31! ;HJJ!
HPSOR\PHQW RSSRUWXQLWLHV IRU DOO 7RZDUGV WKLV HQG LW VKDOO EH WKH 6WDWH·V
61G2<:G=5=J=3C! 3<! 26<31B3! 3F1! <A16G1?G! P=J=2=:<! O<6K16G! L#P.GMN! *F1! #A16G1?G!
.<6K16G!.1J;?61!/@4=:=G36?3=<:!L#../M!O=JJ!51!3F1!26=4?6C!=:G36H41:3?J=3C!<;!3F1!
03?31!3<!G16A1!?:@!26<4<31!3F1!=:3161G3!?:@!O1J;?61!<;!3F1!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!!!
&F?2316!%%!!
0-&N! `N! )?3H61! <;! #../! ?G! ?! Z<A16:41:3! V<@CN! ²! *F1! #../! =G! ?! :?3=<:?J!
><A16:41:3!?>1:BC!A1G31@!O=3F!?!G21B=?J!;H:B3=<:!<;!@1A1J<2=:>!?:@!=42J141:3=:>!
O1J;?61!26<>6?4G!?:@!G16A=B1G!3F?3!?61!61G2<:G=A1!3<!3F1!:11@G!<;!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!
51:1;=B=?6=1GN!%3!=G!1:@<O1@!O=3F!2<O16G!3<!?@4=:=G316!?!36HG3!;H:@N!%3G!<;;=B=?JG!?:@!
142J<C11G!?61!B<A161@!5C!3F1!0?J?6C!03?:@?6@=U?3=<:!$?ON!!
0-&! _N! "H62<G1G! ?:@! #5d1B3=A1GN! %:! <6@16! 3<! 61?;;=64! 3F1! 4?:@?31! 1G2<HG1@! =:!
/63=BJ1! %%! 01B3=<:! 9a! ?:@! /63=BJ1! n%%%! 01B3=<:! `I! <;! 3F1! 9\a]! &<:G3=3H3=<:I! #../!
GF?JJX!!!
x P?B=J=3?31! 3F1! =42J141:3?3=<:! <;! 3F1! 26<A=G=<:G! <;! 3F1! $?5<6! &<@1!
B<:B16:=:>!3F1!61G2<:G=5=J=3C!<;!3F1!><A16:41:3!3<!26<4<31!3F1!O1JJQ
51=:>!<;!#P.Gc!
x "6<A=@1! G<B=?J! ?:@! O1J;?61! G16A=B1G! 3<! #P.GI! =:BJH@=:>I! 5H3! :<3!
J=4=31@! 3<I! =:GH6?:B1I! G<B=?J! O<6K! ?GG=G3?:B1I! BHJ3H6?J! G16A=B1G! ?:@!
61=:31>6?3=<:!<;!613H6:=:>!#P.Gc!!
x -:GH61!3F1!1;;=B=1:BC!<;!B<JJ1B3=<:G!?:@!3F1!A=?5=J=3C!?:@!GHG3?=:?5=J=3C!
#%"
<;! 3F1! PH:@! 3F6<H>F! G<H:@I! dH@=B=<HGI! ?:@! 36?:G2?61:3! =:A1G341:3!
?:@!4?:?>141:3!2<J=B=1Gc!!
x E:@163?K1!G3H@=1G!?:@!61G1?6BF!;<6!3F1!1:F?:B141:3!<;!#P.!G<B=?JI!
1B<:<4=B!?:@!BHJ3H6?J!O1JJQ51=:>c!?:@!
x D1A1J<2I! GH22<63! ?:@! ;=:?:B1! G21B=;=B! 26<d1B3G! ;<6! 3F1! O1J;?61! <;!
#P.GN!!
&F?2316!%%%!
0-&N! bN! D1;=:=3=<:! <;! *164GN! P<6! 2H62<G1G! <;! 3F=G! /B3I! 3F1! ;<JJ<O=:>! 3164G! GF?JJ!
41?:X!
x V<:?;=@1! #../! (14516! 61;16G! 3<! ?:C! 216G<:! OF<! ;HJ;=JJG! 3F1!
B<:@=3=<:G! 3<!51! 142J<C1@! <6! 1:>?>1@! =:!?! 26<@HB3=A1! 142J<C41:3!
<A16G1?G! <;! OF=BF! F1! <6! GF1! =G! :<3! ?! B=3=U1:! <6! <:! 5<?6@! ?! A1GG1J!
:?A=>?3=:>! 3F1! ;<61=>:! G1?G! <3F16! 3F?:! ?!><A16:41:3! GF=2! HG1@! ;<6!
4=J=3?6C! <6! :<:QB<4416B=?J! 2H62<G1G! <6! ?:! =:G3?JJ?3=<:! J<B?31@!
<;;GF<61! <6! <:! F=>F! G1?GI! ?:@! OF<! F?G! 2?=@! 3F1! 61SH=61@! #../!
414516GF=2!;11c!!
x D121:@1:3G!!
x &<421:G?3=<:!!
x &<:36=5H3=<:! 61;16G! 3<! 3F1! ?4<H:3! 2?C?5J1! 3<! #../! 5C! ?! 5<:?;=@1!
#P.!<6!3F1!142J<C16!=:!?BB<6@?:B1!O=3F!3F1!26<A=G=<:G!<;!3F=G!/B3c!!
x /B3=A1! #../! 414516! 61;16G! 3<! ?:! #P.! OF<! F?G! ?:! ?B3=A1!
142J<C41:3!B<:36?B3!?:@!OF<!F?G!2?=@!3F1!#../!414516GF=2!;11N!
x )<:Q/B3=A1! #../! 414516! 61;16G! 3<! ?:! #P.! OF<G1! #../!
414516GF=2! F?G! 1R2=61@! ?:@! F?G! :<3! 61:1O1@! =3! @1G2=31! F?A=:>! ?!
:1O!142J<C41:3!B<:36?B3!O=3F!3F1!G?41!<6!?:<3F16!142J<C16c!
x )<:Q(14516!#P.!61;16G!3<!?:!H:@<BH41:31@!#P.!?:@!OF<!F?G!:<3!
?A?=J1@!<;!3F1!A<JH:3?6C!414516GF=2!<;!#../!<:QG=31N!
&F?2316!%m!
0-&N! ]N! +1>=G36?3=<:!<;! (14516GF=2N! +1>=G36?3=<:! <6! 1:6<JJ41:3! <;!414516G! GF?JJ!
51! =:! ?BB<6@?:B1! O=3F! 3F1! 26<A=G=<:G! <;! 3F=G! /B3N! (14516GF=2! =:! #../! 4?C! 51!
<53?=:1@!=:!3O<!L7M!O?CGX!
x VC!B<42HJG<6C!61>=G36?3=<:!H2<:!26<B1GG=:>!<;!142J<C41:3!B<:36?B3G!
<;!:1OQF=61GI!61F=61GI!@=61B3QF=61GI!><A16:41:3QF=61G!?3!3F1!"#-/c!?:@!!
x VC!A<JH:3?6C!61>=G36?3=<:!<;!:<:Q?B3=A1!414516G!?:@!H:@<BH41:31@!
#P.G!?3!d<5QG=31G!<A16G1?GN!
0-&N!aN!"6<<;!<;!(14516GF=2N!!
0-&N!98N!+1:1O?J!<;!(14516GF=2N!(14516GF=2!GF?JJ!51!61:1O1@!H2<:!2?C41:3!<;!
B<:36=5H3=<:!<:!B<:36?B3!61:1O?J[=GGH?:B1!<;!:1O!B<:36?B3N!%:!3F1!B?G1!<;!A<JH:3?6C!
#&"
414516GF=2I! B<A16?>1! GF?JJ! 51! 61:1O1@!H2<:!2?C41:3! <;! B<:36=5H3=<:! <;! *O1:3C!
P=A1!E0!D<JJ?6G!LE0!f7_N88M!<6!=3G!1SH=A?J1:3!=:!3F1!BH661:3!;<61=>:!1RBF?:>1!6?31GN!!
*F161!GF?JJ!51!?!>6?B1!216=<@!<;!3O<!L7M!4<:3FG!=:!5<3F!=:G3?:B1GN!
0-&N!99N!012?6?3=<:!<;!01?Q5?G1@!?:@!$?:@Q5?G1@!.<6K16G!&<:36=5H3=<:GN!*<!1;;1B3!
?! 4<61! 1;;=B=1:3! ;H:@! 4?:?>141:3! 513O11:! 3F1! 3O<! L7M! GH5QG1B3<6?J! >6<H2G! <;!
$?:@Q5?G1@! ?:@! 01?Q5?G1@! O<6K16GI! 3F1! B<JJ1B3=<:! <;! 414516GF=2! B<:36=5H3=<:!
GF?JJ!51!?BB<H:31@!;<6!=:!3O<!L7M!G12?6?31!5<<KG!<;!?BB<H:3N!
0-&N! 9_N! "6<F=5=3=<:! ?>?=:G3! @=GB6=4=:?3=<:! <:! 414516GF=2! 3<! 3F1! #../N! )<!
5<:?;=@1!#P.!GF?JJ!51! @1:=1@! ?@4=GG=<:!3<! 3F1! #../!5C! 61?G<:! <;!?>1I! >1:@16I!
:?3=<:?J=3CI!61J=>=<HG! 51J=1;I!<6!2<J=3=B?J!<2=:=<:!<6! ?;;=J=?3=<:N!*F1!#../!GF?JJ! 3?K1!
?;;=64?3=A1!G312G!3<!1:F?:B1!3F1!?BB1GG!<;!<A16G1?G!P=J=2=:<G!?:@!4=>6?:3!P=J=2=:<!
O<6K16G!3<!=3G!26<>6?4G!?:@!G16A=B1GN!
0-&!9bN!"?C41:3!<;!&<:36=5H3=<:!<6!#../!P11!5C!-42J<C16N!²!&<:36=5H3=<:G!3<!3F1!
#../!*6HG3!PH:@!4HG3!51!2?=@!5C!3F1!142J<C16G[26=:B=2?JI!<6!=:!3F1=6!@1;?HJ3I!3F1!
61B6H=341:3[4?::=:>!?>1:BC!=:!3F1!B?G1!<;!:1OQF=61GN!*F1!"#-/!GF?JJ!1:GH61!3F?3!
?!26<A=G=<:!3<!3F=G!1;;1B3!GF?JJ!51!4?@1!?:!=:31>6?J!2?63!<;!3F1!B<:36?B3!;<6!<A16G1?G!
142J<C41:3N!!
&F?2316!m!
0-&N9\N! *F1! #../! V<?6@! <;! *6HG311GN! Q! *<! B?66C! <H3! 3F1! 2H62<G1G! <;! 3F=G! /B3I!
#../!GF?JJ!51!@=61B31@!?:@!B<:36<JJ1@!5C!?!V<?6@!<;!*6HG311G!?G!=3G!2<J=BC!4?K=:>!
5<@CN!%3!GF?JJ!51!B<42<G1@!<;!3F1!;<JJ<O=:>!414516GX!
x 01B613?6C!<;!$?5<6!?:@!-42J<C41:3I!?G!&F?=6216G<:c!
x #../!/@4=:=G36?3<6I!?G!m=B1!&F?=6216G<:c!!
x 01B613?6C!<;!P<61=>:!/;;?=6Gc!
x 01B613?6C!<;!P=:?:B1c!
x 01B613?6C!<;!VH@>13!?:@!(?:?>141:3c!
x "#-/!/@4=:=G36?3<6c!
x #:1!L9M!61261G1:3?3=A1!;6<4!3F1!J?:@Q5?G1@!61B6H=341:3!G1B3<6I!OF<!
=G! G1J1B31@! ;6<4! ?4<:>! 3F1! A?6=<HG! ?GG<B=?3=<:G! <;! 61>=G3161@!
<A16G1?G! 2J?B141:3! ?:@! 61B6H=341:3! ?>1:B=1G! 5?G1@! =:! 3F1!
"F=J=22=:1G!OF<!GF?JJ!51!?22<=:31@!5C!3F1!"61G=@1:3!3<!G16A1!?!G=:>J1!
3164!<;!3F611!L`M!C1?6Gc!!
x #:1! L9M! 61261G1:3?3=A1! ;6<4! 3F1! G1?Q5?G1@! 4?::=:>! G1B3<6I! OF<! =G!
G1J1B31@!;6<4!?4<:>!3F1!A?6=<HG!?GG<B=?3=<:G!<;!61>=G3161@!<A16G1?G!
2J?B141:3! ?:@! 61B6H=341:3! ?>1:B=1G! 5?G1@! =:! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1G! OF<!
GF?JJ!51!?22<=:31@!5C!3F1!"61G=@1:3!3<!G16A1!?!G=:>J1!3164!<;!3F611!L`M!
C1?6Gc!!
x *O<! L7M! 61261G1:3?3=A1G! ;6<4! 3F1! J?:@Q5?G1@! #P.G! OF<! ?61!
:<4=:?31@! ?:@! ?22<=:31@! =:! ?BB<6@?:B1! O=3F! 3F1! 26<A=G=<:G! <;!
+12H5J=B!/B3!)<N!98877c!!
#3"
x *O<! L7M! 61261G1:3?3=A1G! ;6<4! 3F1! G1?Q5?G1@! #P.G! OF<! ?61!
:<4=:?31@! ?:@! ?22<=:31@! =:! ?BB<6@?:B1! O=3F! 3F1! 26<A=G=<:G! <;!
+12H5J=B!/B3!)<N!98877c!?:@!
x *O<!L7M!61261G1:3?3=A1G!;6<4!3F1!O<41:!G1B3<6!OF<!?61! :<4=:?31@!
?:@!?22<=:31@!=:!?BB<6@?:B1!O=3F!3F1!26<A=G=<:G!<;!+12H5J=B!/B3!)<N!
98877c!
0-&N! 79N! +1G2<:G=5=J=3=1G! ?:@! "<O16G! <;! 3F1! V<?6@! <;! *6HG311GN! *F1! V<?6@! GF?JJ!
1R16B=G1!3F1!;<JJ<O=:>!G21B=;=B!2<O16G!?:@!@H3=1GX!
x *<!@1;=:1!3F1!3F6HG3G!<;!3F1!#../!?:@!?@<23!56<?@!2<J=BC!>H=@1J=:1G!
3<!1:GH61!3F1=6!=42J141:3?3=<:c!
x *<!261G16A1!3F1!=:31>6=3C!<;!3F1!#../!*6HG3!PH:@c!
x *<! ?226<A1! 26<>6?4GI! 26<d1B3GI! ?:@! 3F1! <6>?:=U?3=<:?J! G36HB3H61! <;!
3F1!#../!01B613?6=?3c!
x *<! ;=R! 3F1! 414516GF=2! ;11! ?:@! <3F16! :1B1GG?6C! BF?6>1GI! ?G! 3F1!
V<?6@!4?C!@114!26<216!3<!=42<G1c!
x *<! ;<64HJ?31! 6HJ1G! ?:@! 61>HJ?3=<:G! ><A16:=:>! ;=:?:B=?J! 36?:G?B3=<:G!
?:@!;=R!3F1!C1?6JC!?226<26=?3=<:G!<;!3F1!01B613?6=?3c!?:@!!!
x *<! 1:GH61! 3F1! 1;;=B=1:BC! <;! B<JJ1B3=<:! ?:@! 3F1! A=?5=J=3C! ?:@!
GHG3?=:?5=J=3C! <;! 3F1! ;H:@! 3F6<H>F! G<H:@! ?:@! dH@=B=<HG! =:A1G341:3!
?:@!;H:@!4?:?>141:3!2<J=B=1Gc!!
x *<!61B1=A1!?:@! ?226<26=?31!?JJ!GH4G! ?G!4?C!51!26<A=@1@! 5C!J?O! ;<6!
3F1!GH22<63!<;!3F1!#../!3<!3F1!1:@G!G21B=;=1@!5C!J?OI!?:@!?JJ!<3F16!
GH4G!=:!3F1!4?::16!=3!4?CI!=:!=3G!@=GB613=<:I!@13164=:1!3<!B?66C!<H3!
3F1!2H62<G1G!?:@!;H:B3=<:G!<;!3F1!#../c!
x *<! ?H3F<6=U1! 3F1! B<:G36HB3=<:! <6! 612?=6! <;! =3G! 5H=J@=:>GI! 4?BF=:16CI!
1SH=241:3!?:@!<3F16!;?B=J=3=1GI!?:@!3F1!2H6BF?G1!?:@!?BSH=G=3=<:!<;!
61?J! ?:@! 216G<:?J! 26<2163=1GI! =:BJH@=:>! 3F1! :1B1GG?6C! GH22J=1GI!
4?316=?JG!?:@!1SH=241:3c!!
x *<!61B1=A1!=:!36HG3!J1>?B=1GI!>=;3G!?:@!@<:?3=<:G!<;!61?J!?:@!216G<:?J!
26<2163C!<;!?JJ!K=:@G!?:@!3<!?@4=:=G316!?:@!@=G2<G1!3F1!G?41!OF1:!
:1B1GG?6C! ;<6! 3F1! 51:1;=3! <;! 3F1! #../! >1:16?J! 414516GF=2! ?:@!
GH5d1B3!3<!3F1!=:G36HB3=<:G!<;!3F1!@<:<6I!=;!?:Cc!
x *F1! 26<A=G=<:G! <;! J?O! 3<! 3F1! B<:36?6C! :<3O=3FG3?:@=:>I! 3<! ?H3F<6=U1!
?:C!<;!=3G!V<?6@!414516!3<!36?A1J!?56<?@!;<6!B163?=:!G21B=;=B!2H62<G1!
61J?3=A1!3<!F=G[F16!;H:B3=<:GX!"6<A=@1@I!*F?3!GHBF!36?A1J!=G!O=3F=:!3F1!
GB<21!?:@!;H:B3=<:G!<;!3F1!4?:@?31!<;!#../I!?G!261GB6=51@!F161=:c!!
x *<!1R16B=G1!3F1!>1:16?J!2<O16G!G13!<H3!=:!3F1!&<62<6?3=<:!&<@1c!
x *<!@1J1>?31!?:C!<;!=3G!2<O16G!3<!3F1!&F?=6216G<:!<;!3F1!#../!V<?6@!
<6!?:C!<3F16!<;;=B=?JG!<6!<;;=B16G!?G!=3!4?C!@114!:1B1GG?6Cc!!
x *<! 261GB6=51! GHBF! >1:16?J! 2<J=B=1GI! 6HJ1G! ?:@! 61>HJ?3=<:GI! :<3!
B<:36?6C! 3<! J?OI! ?G! ?61! B<:G=G31:3! O=3F! 3F1! 2H62<G1G!<;! 3F1! #../c!!
?:@!
x *<! 1R16B=G1! GHBF! 2<O16G!?G! 4?C! 51! 26<216! ?:@! :1B1GG?6C! 3<! B?66C!
<H3!3F1!<5d1B3=A1G!<;!3F=G!/B3N!
!
&F?2316!m%%!
#2"
0-&N! 7^N! *F1! #../! 01B613?6=?3N! ²! *F1! 01B613?6=?3! GF?JJ! ;H:B3=<:! ?G! 3F1!
=42J141:3=:>!?64!<;!#../N!!
0-&N!7_N!*F1!#../!/@4=:=G36?3<6N!²!*F1!?@4=:=G36?3=<:!<;!3F1!#../!=G!A1G31@!=:!
3F1!/@4=:=G36?3<6!=:G<;?6!?G!?H3F<6=U1@!5C!3F1!V<?6@N!/G!3F1!&F=1;!-R1BH3=A1!#;;=B16!
<;! 3F1! 01B613?6=?3I! 3F1! /@4=:=G36?3<6! ?@4=:=G316G! 3F1! <A16?JJ! <216?3=<:G! <;! 3F1!
01B613?6=?3N! ,1! 1R16B=G1G! >1:16?J! GH216A=G=<:! ?:@!B<:36<J!<;! ?JJ!=3G! 216G<::1J! ?:@!
61G<H6B1GI!?:@!?GGH41G!;HJJ!61G2<:G=5=J=3C!?:@!?BB<H:3?5=J=3C!3F161<;N!!
! *F1!/@4=:=G36?3<6!GF?JJ!51!?22<=:31@!5C!3F1!"61G=@1:3N!,1!4HG3!2<GG1GG!
><<@! J1?@16GF=2! ?:@! 4?:?>16=?J! GK=JJG! ?:@! GF?JJ! F?A1! 3F1! 6?:K! <;! ?! D12?6341:3!
E:@16G1B613?6CN! *F1! /@4=:=G36?3<6! GF?JJ! 612<63! 3<! 3F1! "61G=@1:3! 3F6<H>F! 3F1!
01B613?6C!<;!D#$-I!?:@!GF?JJ!216;<64!3F1!@H3=1G!?:@!;H:B3=<:G!1JG1OF161!G3?31@!=:!
3F=G! /B3! ?:@! ?JJ! 3F1! HGH?JI! :1B1GG?6C! ?:@! 61J?31@! ;H:B3=<:G! <;! 3F1! <;;=B1! <;! 3F1!
/@4=:=G36?3<6I!GH5d1B3!3<!3F1!2<J=B=1G!?:@!6HJ1G!261GB6=51@!5C!3F1!V<?6@N!*F1!V<?6@!
GF?JJ!@13164=:1!3F1!3164!<;!<;;=B1!?:@!B<421:G?3=<:!<;!3F1!/@4=:=G36?3<6N!
0-&N!7bN! *F1! D12H3C! /@4=:=G36?3<6GN! ²! *O<!L7M!D12H3C!/@4=:=G36?3<6G!GF?JJ! ?GG=G3!
3F1! /@4=:=G36?3<6! =:! 3F1! ?@4=:=G36?3=<:! ?:@! GH216A=G=<:! <;! <216?3=<:G! <;! #../N!
*F1C! GF?JJ! 51! ?22<=:31@! 5C! 3F1! V<?6@! H2<:! 3F1! 61B<441:@?3=<:! <;! 3F1!
/@4=:=G36?3<6N!*F1C!4HG3!?JG<!2<GG1GG!><<@!J1?@16GF=2!?:@!4?:?>16=?J!GK=JJG!?:@!
GF?JJ!F?A1!3F1!6?:K!<;!?!D12?6341:3!/GG=G3?:3!01B613?6CN!*F1!V<?6@!GF?JJ!@13164=:1!
3F1=6!3164G!<;!<;;=B1!?:@!B<421:G?3=<:N! *F1! V<?6@!4?C!?GG=>:!G21B=;=B!;H:B3=<:?J!
61G2<:G=5=J=3=1G!3<!3F1!D12H3C!/@4=:=G36?3<6GN!
01B3=<:!7]N!+1>=<:?J!?:@!#:Q0=31!#;;=B16GN!²!#../!GF?JJ!4?=:3?=:!+1>=<:?J!#;;=B1G!
?:@! <:QG=31! .1J;?61! #;;=B1G! H:@16! 3F1! "F=J=22=:1! #A16G1?G! $?5<6! #;;=B1G! <;! 3F1!
D12?6341:3! <;! $?5<6N! *F1! G?J?6=1G! ?:@! ?JJ<O?:B1G! <;! .1J;?61! #;;=B16G! GF?JJ! 51!
@13164=:1@!5C!3F1!V<?6@I!GH5d1B3!3<!3F1!0?J?6C!03?:@?6@=U?3=<:!$?ON!
&F?2316!%n!V1:1;=3G!?:@!016A=B1G!!!
0-&!^8N!!V1:1;=3G!?:@!016A=B1G!3<!#P.GN!²!!
/N +12?36=?3=<:!/GG=G3?:B1N!
x /JJ!#P.G!=:!@=G361GG!GF?JJ!51!1:GH61@!<;!612?36=?3=<:!?GG=G3?:B1!
;6<4! #../! OF161! :11@1@I! GH5d1B3! 3<! 61=45H6G141:3! 5C! 3F1!
;<61=>:! 142J<C16[26=:B=2?J[?>1:BC! B<:B16:1@I! <6! 5<6:1! 5C! 3F1!
#../!=;!3F1!216G<:G!41:3=<:1@!F161=:!?61!:<3!=@1:3=;=1@I!?G!3F1!
B?G1!4?C!51N!
x %:! B?G1! <;! 1416>1:BC! 4?GG! 612?36=?3=<:GI! 3F1! #../! ?:@! 3F1!
DP/I! O=3F! ;HJJ! GH22<63! ;6<4! 3F1! :?3=<:?J! ><A16:41:3I! GF?JJ!
H:@163?K1!4?GG!612?36=?3=<:G[1A?BH?3=<:G!?G!4?C!51!:1B1GG?6CN!
*F1! B<G3! GF?JJ! 51!GF<HJ@161@! =:! ?BB<6@?:B1! O=3F! 3F1!;<61><=:>!
BJ?GG=;=B?3=<:N!
x *F1! 612?36=?3=<:! <;! 614?=:G! <;! @1B1?G1@! P=J=2=:<G! ?56<?@! GF?JJ!
?22JC!3F1!G?41!?331:@?:3!B=6BH4G3?:B1GN!
#4"
!
VN !$<?:!?:@!&61@=3!/GG=G3?:B1N!
%:! B<42J=?:B1! O=3F! /63=BJ1! %%%I! 01B3=<:! 79! <;! +/! a8^7I! #../! GF?JJ!
B<<6@=:?31! O=3F! ><A16:41:3! ;=:?:B=:>! =:G3=3H3=<:G! LZP%GM! 3<! 26<A=@1!
J<OQB<JJ?316?J! J<?:G! 3<! #P.GN! *F1! J<?:G! GF?JJ! 51! >6?:31@! 3F6<H>F!
@1G=>:?31@!:?3=<:?J!5?:KG!?@<23=:>!?!G21B=?J!J<OQB<JJ?316?J!6?31N!*F1!
#P.! GF?JJ! 26<A=@1! 7[`! <;! 3F1! B<JJ?316?J! 61SH=6141:3! OF=J1! #../!
GF?JJ!5<6:1!3F1!614?=:=:>!9[`!<;!3F1!B<JJ?316?JN!
x "61QD12?63H61! $<?:G! L"D$M! GF?JJ! G16A=B1! 61?@CQ3<QJ1?A1I! :1OJC!
F=61@! #P.G! OF<G1! 142J<C16G! <6!?>1:3G! F?A1! ?J61?@C! 2?=@! 3F1!
B<42HJG<6C!#../!;11N!*F1! J<?:! =G!@1G=>:1@!3<!?GG=G3! #P.G!=:!
3F1=6!261Q@12?63H61!:11@GI!GHBF!?G!2?C41:3!<;!2J?B141:3!;11GI!
BJ<3F=:>! 61SH=6141:3GI! 2<BK13! 4<:1CI! ?:@! <3F16! 261Q@12?63H61!
1R21:G1GN!!
x P?4=JC! /GG=G3?:B1! $<?:G! LP/$M! =G! ?A?=J?5J1! ;<6! 1416>1:BC! ?:@!
<3F16!;?4=JC!:11@G!?G!1:@<6G1@!5C!3F1!#P.N!!
x +13H6:11! $<?:G! L+$M! GF?JJ! 51! ?A?=J?5J1! ;<6! 613H6:=:>! #P.G! 3<!
?GG=G3!=:!61=:31>6?3=<:I!G133J141:3I!?:@!<3F16!:11@GN!
x -:361261:1H6=?J!$<?:G!L-$M!GF?JJ!51!?A?=J?5J1!3<!#P.G!<:QG=31!<6!
3<! 613H6:1@! 3<!?GG=G3! =:! 1G3?5J=GF=:>! :1O! 5HG=:1GG1G!?:@! <3F16!
1:361261:1H6=?J!A1:3H61GN!
&N !.<6K16G!/GG=G3?:B1N!
x &<:3=:H=:>! -@HB?3=<:! ?:@! &<H:G1J=:>! ?5<H3! #P.! 016A=B1G! ?:@!
+1G<H6B1GN! #../! GF?JJ!B<:3=:H1!3<! @=GG14=:?31! =:;<64?3=<:!3<!
<:QG=31! ?:@! 613H6:1@! #P.G! 61>?6@=:>! ?JJ! ?A?=J?5J1! #../!
G16A=B1G! ?:@! 61G<H6B1GI! =:BJH@=:>! 5H3! :<3! J=4=31@! 3<! 3F<G1!
1:H416?31@!=:!/63=BJ1!%%%I!01B3=<:!^!<;!3F=G!/B3N!!
x &<:3=:H1@! /GG=G3?:B1! #53?=:=:>! #P.! 016A=B1G! ?:@! /BB1GG=:>!
#P.!+1G<H6B1GN!#../!O=JJ!?GG=G3!?:C!=:3161G31@!#P.!3<!?A?=J!<;!
3F1!51:1;=3G!?:@!G16A=B1G!1:H416?31@!=:!/63=BJ1!%%%I!01B3=<:!^!<;!
3F=G!/B3N!
!
DN #:QG=31!016A=B1GN!!
#../! GF?JJ! GHG3?=:! ?:@! 4?=:3?=:! ?GG=G3?:B1! 3<! #P.G! =:! ?JJ! =3G!
61>=<:?J! ?:@! <A16G1?G! <;;=B1GN! 016A=B1G! GF?JJ! =:BJH@1! =:;<64?3=<:!
61>?6@=:>! 3F1! :?41GI! <BBH2?3=<:[d<5! B?31><6C! ?:@! ?@@61GG1G! <;!
#P.I!26<A=@=:>!>H=@?:B1I!@1A1J<2=:>!4?316=?JG!;<6!3F1!"61QD12?63H61!
#6=1:3?3=<:! 014=:?6GI! B<:@HB3=:>! 2GCBF<QG<B=?J! B<H:G1J=:>I!
B<:B=J=?3=<:! G16A=B1GI! ?:@! <H361?BF! 4=GG=<:GI! ?4<:>! <3F16GN! #:!
51F?J;! <;! 3F1! #P.I! #../! 4?C! 26<A=@1! ?226<26=?31! 61261G1:3?3=<:!
O=3F! 142J<C16GI! ?>1:3G! ?:@!F<G3! ><A16:41:3!?H3F<6=3=1GI! =:BJH@=:>I!
5H3!:<3!J=4=31@!3<!?GG=G3=:>!#P.G!3<!61>?=:!H:2?=@!O?>1GN!
#7"
-N!D1?3F!?:@!D=G?5=J=3C!V1:1;=3GN!
PN!+1=:31>6?3=<:!<;!#P.GN!
*F1!;<61><=:>!51:1;=3G[G16A=B1G!GF?JJ!51!>=A1:!3<!2?C=:>[?B3=A1!414516G!
<;! #../! OF=J1! ;<6416! 2?C=:>! 414516G! ?:@! :<:Q414516G! <;! #../! GF?JJ! 1:d<C!
51:1;=3G[G16A=B1G!D!?:@!PI!?:@!<3F16!51:1;=3G[G16A=B1G!OF=BF!GF?JJ!51!@13164=:1@!
5C!3F1!#../!V<?6@N!!
0-&N! ^9N! ZH=@=:>! "6=:B=2J1GN! Q!"H6GH?:3! 3<!=3G! 4?:@?31I!#../! GF?JJ!@1J=A16! 3<!?JJ!
414516Q#P.GI! J<?:! ?GG=G3?:B1I! 1@HB?3=<:! ?:@! GK=JJG! 36?=:=:>I! G<B=?J! G16A=B1GI!
;?4=JC! O1J;?61! ?GG=G3?:B1I! ?:@! <3F16! ?226<26=?31! 26<>6?4G! 3F?3! 26<A=@1! 3=41JC!
G<B=?JI!?:@!1B<:<4=B!G16A=B1GN!
)<3F=:>!=:!3F=G!/B3!GF?JJ!51!B<:G36H1@!?G!?!J=4=3?3=<:!<6!@1:=?J!<;!3F1!6=>F3!
<;!3F1!#P.!3<!?A?=J!<;!?:C!51:1;=3!2J?:!OF=BF!4?C!51!?@<231@!=:!3F1!142J<C41:3!
B<:36?B3I!<6!<;;161@!A<JH:3?6=JC!5C!142J<C16GI!<6!5C!3F1!J?OG!<;!3F1!61B1=A=:>!B<H:36C!
OF=BF!?61!<A16!?:@!?5<A1!3F<G1!26<A=@1@!H:@16!!3F=G!/B3N!!
0-&N!^7N!&<44=341:3!3<!-R31:@!016A=B1!3<!)<:Q414516G!?:@!+14?=:!+1G2<:G=A1!
3<!#P.!61SH=6141:3GN!²!#../! GF?JJ!?JG<!1R31:@!=3G!G16A=B1G!?:@!26<>6?4GI!GHBF!
?G!1@HB?3=<:!?:@!GK=JJG!36?=:=:>I!G<B=?J!G16A=B1GI!?:@!<3F16!?226<26=?31!26<>6?4G!3<!
:<:Q414516G!<6!H:@<BH41:31@!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!!!
#../! GF?JJ! B<:3=:H1! 3<! G11K! :1O! O?CG! 3<! G16A1! #P.! O1J;?61I! 3<! 4113!
:1O!#P.!:11@G!?:@!61SH=6141:3G!?G!3F1C!?6=G1I!?:@!3<!?GG1GG!3F1!1;;1B3=A1:1GG!<;!
1R=G3=:>!G16A=B1G!?:@!51:1;=3G!=:!G16A=:>!#P.!O1J;?61N!
#../!GF?JJ!?JG<!4?=:3?=:!?:!=:316?B3=A1!O15G=31!3<!B<JJ1B3!#P.!;11@5?BK!
<:!1R=G3=:>!G16A=B1GI!B<441:3GI!GH>>1G3=<:GI!?:@!B<42J?=:3GN!!
&F?2316!n!#../!*6HG3!PH:@!!
0-&N!^`N!#../!PH:@N!Q!*F1!#../!PH:@!=G!?!26=A?31!;H:@!F1J@!=:!36HG3!5C!#../N!
*F1!#../!PH:@I!51=:>!?!36HG3!;H:@I!=G!:<3!><A16:41:3!4<:1CN!)<!2<63=<:!3F161<;!
<6!?:C!<;!=3G!=:B<41I!@=A=@1:@G!<6!1?6:=:>G!GF?JJ!?BB6H1!3<!3F1!>1:16?J!;H:@!<;!3F1!
)?3=<:?J! Z<A16:41:3N! )1=3F16! GF?JJ! ?:C! ?4<H:3! <6! 2<63=<:! 3F161<;! 51! B<:d<=:1@!
O=3F! 3F1! ><A16:41:3! 4<:1CI! :<6! 61A163! 3<! 3F1! :?3=<:?J! ><A16:41:3N! %:! 3F1! G?41!
PDQQHULWLVH[HPSWHGIURPWKH´RQHIXQGGRFWULQHµRIWKHJRYHUQPHQW!
0-&N!^^N!!"H62<G1!<;!3F1!#../!PH:@N!Q!*F1!#../!PH:@!B?:!<:JC!51!HG1@!;<6!3F1!
2H62<G1G!;<6!OF=BF!=3!O?G!B61?31@I!3F?3!=GI!3<!1RBJHG=A1JC!!G16A1!3F1!O1J;?61!<;!#P.G!
?:@! 3F1=6! 51:1;=B=?6=1GN! *F1! ;H:@! =G! 3<! 51! HG1@! 1RBJHG=A1JC! 3<! ;=:?:B1! 3F1! B<61!
26<>6?4G! ?:@! G16A=B1G! <;! 3F1! #../I! ;H63F16I! :<3! J1GG! 3F?:! `8g! <;! 3F1=6! ?::H?J!
B<JJ1B3=<:!GF?JJ!51!?JJ<B?31@!;<6!61=:31>6?3=<:!26<>6?4N!
$6"
01B3=<:!^]N!0<H6B1!<;!3F1!#../!PH:@N!Q!*F1!#../!*6HG3!PH:@!=G!3F1!GH4!3<3?J!<;!
3F1! ?4<H:3G! BH661:3JC! H:@16! 3F1! 4?:?>141:3! ?:@! ;=GB?J! ?@4=:=G36?3=<:! <;! 3F1!
#../! V<?6@! ?:@! 3F1! 01B613?6=?3I! =:BJH@=:>! ! 3F1! E0f7_! B<:36=5H3=<:G! 3F?3! GF?JJ!
?BB6H1!3<!3F1!;H:@!?G!;11GI!=:A1G341:3!?:@!=:3161G3!=:B<41I!?:@!=:B<41!;6<4!<3F16!
G<H6B1GN!
01B3=<:!^aN!*6HG311G!<;!3F1!PH:@N!Q!*F1!#../!V<?6@!=G!@1G=>:?31@!?G!3F1!36HG311!<;!
3F1!PH:@N!%3!=G!5<H:@!5C!?!;=@HB=?6C!@H3C!3<!4?:?>1!3F1!PH:@!O=3F!3F1!GK=JJI!B?61!?:@!
@=J=>1:B1!<;!?!26H@1:3!216G<:!:1B1GG?6C!H:@16!3F1!B=6BH4G3?:B1GN!
01B3=<:! ^\N! *6?:G2?61:BCN! Q! *F1! #../! *6HG3! 4HG3! 51! 4?:?>1@! O=3F! ;HJJ!
36?:G2?61:BC!?:@!=3!GF?JJ!4?K1!?A?=J?5J1!?JJ!61B<6@G!<;!F<O!3F1!;H:@G!?61!=:A1G31@!
?:@!@=G36=5H31@N!
&F?2316!!n%!%:A1G341:3!/@4=:=G36?3=<:!0?;1>H?6@G!!
0-&N! ^aN! 0?;1>H?6@G! <;! #../! *6HG3! PH:@c! /BSH=61@! /GG13GX! E:61@1141@!
%:A1G341:3G!?:@!#3F16!+1B1=A?5J1GN!!
x *F1! #../! *6HG3! PH:@! GF?JJ! 51! 4?:?>1@! ?:@! 1R21:@1@! =:! ?BB<6@?:B1!
O=3F!3F1!2H62<G1!<;!3F1!PH:@!?:@!G?;1>H?6@1@!?>?=:G3!?:C!2<GG=5J1!J<GG!
?:@!4=GHG1N!!
*F1!#../!GF?JJ!1:GH61!?:!?226<26=?31!>6<O3F!6?31!=:!3F1!;H:@!GH;;=B=1:3!
3<! GHG3?=:! 3F1! >6<O=:>! :11@G! <;! #P.! 414516GN! %3! GF?JJ! 1:GH61! 3F?3! ?JJ!
=:A1G341:3!=:G36H41:3G!?61!216=<@=B?JJC!=:A1:3<6=1@!?:@!26<216JC!K123!?3!?!
><A16:41:3!5?:K!H:@16!?!BHG3<@=?:GF=2!?>61141:3N!!
/!4<:3FJC!612<63!<:!?JJ!=:A1G341:3!GBF1@HJ1G!GF<O=:>!3F1!=:3161G3!6?31GI!
C=1J@GI!@=GB<H:3!6?31GI!?:@!<3F16!61J1A?:3!@?3?I!GF?JJ!51!GH54=331@!3<!3F1!
V<?6@N!!
x *F1!#../!GF?JJ!?@4=:=G316!?JJ!26<2163=1GI!?BSH=61@!<6!;<61BJ<G1@N!!
x E:61@1141@! =:A1G341:3G! ?:@! <3F16! 61B1=A?5J1G! GF?JJ! 51! =:A1:3<6=1@!
G14=Q?::H?JJC!?:@! B<661G2<:@=:>!61@1423=<:!2J?:! GF?JJ!51!GH54=331@!3<!
3F1!V<?6@N!
0-&!^\N!Z1:16?J!%:A1G341:3!"<J=BCN!Q!/JJ!#../!=:A1G341:3G!GF?JJ!51!2J?B1@!<:JC!=:!
><A16:41:3! G1BH6=3=1G! ?:@! 5<:@G! OF=BF! 26<A=@1! <23=4H4! 1?6:=:>GI! J=SH=@=3C! ?:@!
26<31B3=<:! <;! 3F1! PH:@N! "<63;<J=<! 4?:?>141:3! <;! =:A1G3=5J1! ;H:@G! GF?JJ! 51!
<H3G<H6B1@!3<!><A16:41:3!;=:?:B=?J!=:G3=3H3=<:G!LZP%GMN!
! %3!GF?JJ!J=K1O=G1!51!1R1423!;6<4!?:C!?:@!?JJ!;11GI!3?R1GI!BF?6>1G!?:@!<3F16!
=42<G=3=<:!?6=G=:>!;6<4!3F1!4?:?>141:3!<;!3F1!=:A1G341:3!<;!3F1!#../!;H:@GN!
0-&N!_8N!-R?4=:?3=<:!?:@!m?JH?3=<:!<;!3F1!PH:@GN!!
$!"
0-&N!_9N!-R1423=<:!;6<4!*?RI!$1>?J! "6<B1GG!?:@!$=1:N!%3!=G!F1615C!@1BJ?61@!3<!51!
3F1! 2<J=BC! <;! 3F1! 03?31! 3F?3! 3F1! ?B3H?6=?J! G<JA1:BC! <;! 3F1! #../! PH:@G! GF?JJ! 51!
261G16A1@! ?:@! 4?=:3?=:1@! ?3! ?JJ! 3=41G! ?:@! 3F?3! B<:36=5H3=<:! 6?31G! :1B1GG?6C! 3<!
GHG3?=:!3F1!51:1;=3G!H:@16!3F=G!/B3!GF?JJ!51!K123!?G!J<O!?G!2<GG=5J1!=:!<6@16!:<3!3<!
5H6@1:!1R=G3=:>!#../!414516G! ?:@!<3F16!26<G21B3=A1!414516GN!*?R1G!=42<G1@!
<:!3F1! #../! 31:@! 3<!=42?=6!3F1!?B3H?6=?J! G<JA1:BC!<;!=3G!;H:@G! ?:@!=:B61?G1! 3F1!
B<:36=5H3=<:!6?31!:1B1GG?6C!3<!GHG3?=:!3F1!51:1;=3G!<;!3F=G!/B3N! !
&F?2316!n%%!P=GB?J!?:@!VH@>13!"<J=BC!(?:?>141:3!!
0-&!_7N!#216?3=A1!VH@>13N!Q!*F1!<216?3=A1!5H@>13!4HG3!51!GH;;=B=1:3!3<!GH22<63!;HJJ!
26<31B3=<:! <;! 3F1! #P.! O1J;?61N! *F1! 5H@>13! GF?JJ! 51! 61A=1O1@! ?::H?JJC! O=3F!
142F?G=G!<:!?@1SH?31!;H:@=:>!;<6!G16A=B1G!?:@!?>1:BC!1;;=B=1:BCN!
*F1! 414516G! <;! 3F1! V<?6@! GF?JJ! ?226<A1! 5C! ?! H:?:=4<HG! A<31! 3F1!
<216?3=:>! 5H@>13! OF=BF! GF?JJ! GH22<63! 3F1! 2J?::1@! O<6K! 26<>6?4G! ?:@!
?@4=:=G36?3=A1!B<G3G!3<!=:BJH@1!5H3!GF?JJ!:<3!51!J=4=31@!3<!G?J?6=1GI!14<JH41:3G!?:@!
36?:G2<63?3=<:! 1R21:G1G! ;<6! #../! 216G<::1JI! <;;=B1! 61:3?JGI! <;;=B1! GH22J=1GI!
1SH=241:3I! 31BF:<J<>=B?J! GH22<63I! B<44H:=B?3=<:G! ?:@!H3=J=3=1GI! 61SH=6141:3G! ;<6!
216G<:?J!G16A=B1GI!?:@!4?=:31:?:B1N!
*F1! ?226<A1@! <216?3=:>! 5H@>13! GF?JJ! 51! @6?O:! ;6<4! 3F1! #../! *6HG3!
PH:@N!
0-&! _`N! V1:1;=3G! ?:@! 016A=B1G! VH@>13N! Q! *F1! ?::H?J! 5H@>13! GF?JJ! =:BJH@1! ?JJ!
51:1;=3G!?:@!G16A=B1G!3<!#P.GN!!*F1!5H@>13!GF?JJ!26=<6=3=U1!26<31B3=:>!#P.!O1J;?61N!
*F1! ?4<H:3! :1B1GG?6C! 3<!@1;6?C!3F1! B<G3!<;! 3F1G1! 51:1;=3G!?:@! G16A=B1G!GF?JJ! 51!
@6?O:!;6<4!3F1!#../!*6HG3!PH:@N!
0-&! _^N! VH@>13! "612?6?3=<:! ?:@! /226<A?JN! Q! %:! 2612?6=:>! 5<3F! ?::H?J! 5H@>13GI!
#../!GF?JJ!;<JJ<O!3F1!:?3=<:?J!><A16:41:3!5H@>13!GCG314I!;<64?3!?:@!BCBJ1N!
0-&! __N! /H3<4?3=B! /226<26=?3=<:N! %:! B?G1! 3F1! 26<2<G1@! ?::H?J! 5H@>13! F?G! :<3!
511:!?226<A1@!5C!3F1!V<?6@!?3!3F1!G3?63!<;!3F1!C1?6I!#../!GF?JJ!<216?31!O=3F=:!3F1!
5H@>13!J1A1J!<;!3F1!261A=<HG!C1?6!?JJ<B?31@!<:!?!4<:3F!3<!4<:3F!5?G=GN!/JJ!G?A=:>G!
UHDOL]HGZLWKLQDSUHYLRXV\HDUVKDOOEHGHGXFWHGIURPDFXUUHQW\HDU·VEXGJHW!
0-&N! _bN! .<6K! ?:@! P=:?:B=?J! "J?:GN! /JJ! B<G3! B1:316G[<;;=B1G[H:=3G! <;! #../! GF?JJ!
GH54=3! 3F1=6! ?::H?J! O<6K! ?:@! ;=:?:B=?J! 2J?:G! L.P"MI! OF=BF! GF<HJ@! B<661G2<:@! 3<!
3F1!?226<A1@!5H@>13N!*F1!D=61B3<6G!GF?JJ!1:@<6G1!3F1!.P"!<;!3F1=6!61G21B3=A1!H:=3G!
;<6!?226<A?J!<;!3F1!/@4=:=G36?3<6N!*F1!B<:G<J=@?31@!#../Q.P"!GF?JJ!51!612<631@!3<!
3F1!V<?6@N!
0-&N! _]N! VH@>13! +1?J=>:41:3N! +1?J=>:41:3! <;! ;H:@G! =:BJH@=:>! ?@dHG341:3G! =:!
3?6>13G! GF?JJ! 51! GH54=331@! 3<! 3F1! V<?6@! ;<6! ?226<A?JN! 0=4=J?6JCI! =:! 3F1! 1A1:3! 3F?3!
1R36?!<6@=:?6C!B=6BH4G3?:B1G!4?C!<BBH6!OF=BF!61SH=61!?@@=3=<:?J!;H:@G!51C<:@!3F1!
B<A16?>1!<;!3F1!?226<A1@!5H@>13I!3F1!G?41!GF?JJ!51!GH54=331@!;<6!?226<A?J!5C!3F1!
V<?6@N!
$#"
P6<4!#P.GX!&<441:3G!<:!3F1!"6<2<G1@!#../!&F?6316!
*<! 1:GH61! 56<?@! B<:GHJ3?3=<:! <:! 3F1! 26<2<G1@! #../! &F?6316I! 3F1! ,<HG1!
&<44=3311! <:! #A16G1?G! .<6K16G! /;;?=6G! L&#./MI! =:! B<<216?3=<:! O=3F! 3F1!
D12?6341:3! <;!$?5<6!?:@! -42J<C41:3WG! %:316:?3=<:?J! $?5<6! /;;?=6G! VH61?H!D#$-Q
%$/VMI! B<:@HB31@! <:J=:1! B<:GHJ3?3=<:G! O=3F! #P.! >6<H2G! =:! A?6=<HG! @1G3=:?3=<:G
9
N!
&(/!J=K1O=G1!G<J=B=31@!3F1!G?41!;6<4!=3G!2?63:16!#P.!>6<H2G!?:@!=:@=A=@H?JGN!.F=J1!
3F1G1!B<441:3G!4?C!:<3!?H3<4?3=B?JJC!51!2?63!<;!3F1!26<2<G1@!BF?6316I!!3F1G1!?61!
HG1@!?G!61;1UHQFHIRUWKHELOO·VFRQWLQXRXVGHOLEHUDWLRQV%HORZLVDSDUWLDOOLVWRI
3F1=6!=:2H3GX!
#:!(14516GF=2!?:@!&<JJ1B3=<:!
P *F1!!1;;1B3=A=3C!<;!#../!!414516GF=2!51!B<:3=:H<HG!;<6!7!C1?6GI!?:@!:<3!
<:!216! 142J<C16!5?G=G!G<!3F?3!3F1! #P.! @<1G! :<3!F?A1!3<!2?C!1?BF! 3=41!
3F1! #P.! BF?:>1G! 142J<C16! L1N>N! OF1:! #P.! ! >13G! 3164=:?31@! 51;<61!
1R2=6?3=<:!<;!B<:36?B3M!
P *F?3! ;<6! 3F<G1! OF<! O=JJ! ?22JC! ;<6! ! 414516GF=2! <:G=31QQ! 2?C41:3! <;!
414516GF=2! ;11! 51! :<3! ?! 261Q61SH=G=31! 3<! 3F1! =GGH?:B1! <;! #A16G1?G!
-42J<C41:3!&163=;=B?31!L#-&M!
P *<!G36=B3JC!=42J141:3!3F1!2<J=BC!<;!:<3!BF?6>=:>[2?GG=:>!<:!3F1!#../!;11!
3<!#P.!QQ!3<!=:BJH@1!?!26<A=G=<:!=:!3F1!O<6K!B<:36?B3!3F?3!=3!=G!3F1!142J<C16!
3F?3!GF<HJ@!2?C!3F1!414516GF=2!;11!
P #../! GF<HJ@! F?A1! ?! B<42H316=U1@! ?:@! H2Q3<Q@?31! @?3?5?G1! <;! ?JJ! =3G!
414516Gc!GF<HJ@!=GGH1!1QB?6@!
P P<6! 26<;1GG=<:?JG[GK=JJ1@!O<6K16G! !3<! 51! >=A1:!3F1! <23=<:! 3<!2?C! 3F1! ;11!
3F14G1JA1G!L?:@!:<3!3F1!142J<C16!?:C4<61M!!
P ,<O! 3<! ?22JC! ;<6! 414516GF=2! <:G=31! OF1:! 3F161! =G! :<! 2<G3["#$#=:! 3F1!
?61?k!!
P *F?3!#../!414516GF=2!51!<23=<:?J!3<!2164?:1:3!61G=@1:3G!!
P -R2J<61!3F1!2<GG=5=J=3C!3<!=:BJH@1!;<6416!#P.G!OF<!2?=@!3F1=6!414516GF=2!
;11Gc! ?:@! 1R2?:@! A<JH:3?6C! 414516GF=2! 3<! =:BJH@1! 1RQ#P.G! OF<! F?A1!
613H6:1@! 3<! 3F1! B<H:36C! ;<6! ><<@! 5H3! ?61! =:3161G31@! 3<! 2?C! 3F1! 61SH=61@!
414516GF=2! ;11G! 3<! ?A?=J! 3F1! 51:1;=3G! ?G! 61>HJ?6! 414516N! ! /3! 261G1:3I!
G<41!26<>6?4G!?61!;<6!3F1!?B3=A1!414516G!<:JCN!
#:!+1261G1:3?3=<:!
P *F?3!3F161!GF<HJ@!51!4<61!#P.!61261G1:3?3=A1G!=:!3F1!#../!5<?6@!3F?:!
><A16:41:3!61261G1:3?3=A1G!
P *F?3! 3F1! #../! ?@4=:=G36?3<6! ?:@! @12H3C! ?@4=:=G36?3<6G! GF<HJ@! B<41!
;6<4!3F1!#P.!G1B3<6!?:@!3<!51!?22<=:31@!5C!3F1!261G=@1:3!;<6!?!3164!<;!`!
C1?6G!
#:!/A?=J41:3!<;!V1:1;=3G!
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
!
!
This!is!a!first!in!Congress,!by!COW A,!an!online!consultation!via!Skype!with!OFW!
constituents! in!Hong!kong,!Singapore,!Malaysia,!Taiwan,!Jeddah,!Riyadh!and!Al!
Khobar!in!Saudi!Ar abia,!Jordan,!Qatar,!Milan!for!Italy!and!Madrid!for!Spain!
$$"
P 0=42J=;C!26<B1@H61G!;<6!?A?=J41:3!
P *F?3! #P.G! >13! W615?31W! ;<6! 3F1=6! <OO?! B<:36=5H3=<:! <:B1! 3F1C! 613H6:! ;<6!
><<@!?2?63!;6<4!?A?=J41:3!<;!#../!26<>6?4G!?:@!G16A=B1G!
P *F?3!J<?:G!51!B<JJ?316?JQ;611!;<6!;=6G3Q3=41!#P.Gc!=;!3F161!=G!B<JJ?316?JI!7[`!
3<!B<41!;6<4!#../c!9[`!;6<4!><A16:41:3c!!?:<3F16!;<64HJ?!=G!_8g!;6<4!
#P.Gc!_8g!;6<4!><A16:41:3!
P -R2J<61!3F1!2<GG=5=J=3C!<;!21:G=<:!;H:@!;<6!613=6=:>!#P.G!
P -RBJHG=A1! F1?J3F! 51:1;=3G! ;<6! #P.G! ?:@! 3F1=6! 51:1;=B=?6=1G! 4HG3! 51!
G12?6?31!;6<4!3F1!"F=J,1?J3F!
#:!)?3H61!<;!#../!
P %;! #../! >13G! =3G! 5H@>13! ;<6! <216?3=<:G! ?:@! 216G<::1J! G<J1JC! ;6<4! 3F1!
PHPEHUV·FRQWULEXWLRQWKHQJRYHUQPHQWVKRXOGEHKDQGVRII!
P %G!#../!?!Z#&&k!*F1:!=3!=G!!=G!=3!GH5d1B3!3<!BH661:3!:?3=<:?J!J?OG!B<A16=:>!
Z#&&G! ²! ;6<4! 3F1! 3164! <;! <;;=B1! <;! 3F1! *6HG311G! 3<! 3F1! G?J?6C! <;! =3G!
142J<C11G!
P #../!=G!:<3! ?! :?3=<:?J!><A16:41:3!?>1:BCN! !%3!=G!?! 26=A?31!?>1:BC!O=3F!
;H:@G! B<4=:>! ;6<4! 3F1! B<:36=5H3=<:G! <;! #P.G! <:JC! 4?:?>1@! 5C! 3F1!
><A16:41:3!!
#:!*6?:G2?61:BC!
P *F?3!#../!H:@163?K1G!41?GH61G!3<!1:GH61!36?:G2?61:BC!3<!=3G!414516G!
E\ PDNLQJ DYDLODEOH SHULRGLFDOO\ 2::$·V ILQDQFH VWDWHPHQWV DQQXDO
612<63GI!26<>6?4G!?:@!G16A=B1G!
P *F?3!#../!B61?31G[1:GH61G!?!41BF?:=G4!3<!=:;<64!=3G!414516G!?:@!3F1!
2):FRPPXQLW\LQDOOPDWWHUVFRQFHUQLQJ2::$·VRSHUDWLRQV!
#:!&<:GHJ3?3=<:!
P *F?3!?!41BF?:=G4!51!G13!H2!;<6!#P.!61261G1:3?3=A1G!=:!3F1!#../!5<?6@!
3<!H2@?31!?:@!B<:GHJ3!3F1=6!B<:G3=3H1:3G!<:!?!61>HJ?6!5?G=G!
Z1:16?J!"6<2<G?J!
P (?:@?3<6C!61A=1O!<;!3F1!#../!BF?6316!1A16C!;=A1!C1?6G!
$%"
&#)&$E0%#)!
*F1! 1:?B341:3! <;! 3F1! #../! &F?6316! =G! ?! 26=<6=3C! <;! 3F1! ,<HG1! &<44=3311! <:!
2YHUVHDV:RUNHUV·$IIDLUV&2:$ !*F1!&#./!*1BF:=B?J!.<6K=:>!Z6<H2!L*.ZM! =G!
:<O!=:! 3F1!;=:=GF=:>!G3?>1! <;!B<:G<J=@?3=:>! 3F1! 5=JJN!! /:<3F16!*.Z!4113=:>!O=JJ! 51!
B<:@HB31@! O=3F! 3F1! J1>?J! ?:@! 31BF:=B?J! G3?;;! <;! 3F1! #../! 3<! ;=:?J=U1! 3F1!
B<:G<J=@?31@!A16G=<:!<;!3F1!3O<!L7M!5=JJGN!!%3!=G!3?6>131@!3F?3!3F1!B<:G<J=@?31@!A16G=<:!
O=JJ!51!?226<A1@!5C!3F1!&<44=3311!?:@!3F1!26<2<G1@!5=JJ!<:!3F1!#../!&F?6316!51!
GBF1@HJ1@!;<6!2J1:?6C!@1J=516?3=<:G!5C!3F1!;=6G3!SH?6316!<;!:1R3!C1?6N!
*F1!BH661:3!26<B1GG!<;!1:?B3=:>!3F1!#../!&F?6316I!=:!?!O?CI!=G!?!4=:=Q1A?JH?3=<:!<;!
ZKHUH WKH 3KLOLSSLQH JRYHUQPHQW·V FDSDFLW\ WR GHOLYHUVHUYLFHVIRULWV 2):VUHVWV
*F1!;11@5?BK!;6<4!#P.G!?JG<!GF<OG!3F1!=42<63?:B1!<;!@1A=G=:>!G16A=B1G!3?=J<6Q;=3!3<!
WKH LPPHGLDWHDQG FRUH QHHGV RI2):V ZLWKRXW RYHUH[WHQGLQJ WKH JRYHUQPHQW·V
B?2?B=3CN!
V<3F! <6=>=:! ?:@! @1G3=:?3=<:! B<H:36=1G! 2J?C! ?! 4?d<6! 6<J1! =:! 26<31B3=:>! 3F1! 4=>6?:3!
O<6KHUVWKURXJKDQLQVWLWXWLRQDOL]HGZHOIDUHIXQG7KH3KLOLSSLQHV·FDVHKLJKOLJKWV
3F1!=42<63?:B1!<;!@1A1J<2=:>!G3?31!B?2?B=3C!3<!1;;1B3=A1JC!@1J=A16!G16A=B1GI!1:GH6=:>!
?BB<H:3?5=J=3C! 3<! ?:@!61261G1:3?3=<:!<;! 4=>6?:3! O<6K16GI! ?:@! B61?3=:>! 41?:=:>;HJ!
2?63:16GF=2G!O=3F=:!A?6=<HG!><A16:41:3!?>1:B=1G!?G!O1JJ!?G!O=3F!3F1!26=A?31!G1B3<6N!
#:B1!3F1!J=4=3?3=<:G!?:@!5?G=B! =:?@1SH?B=1G!<;!#../!?61!?@@61GG1@!3F6<H>F!3F1!
1:?B341:3!<;!=3G!BF?6316I!!#../I!?G!?:!=:G3=3H3=<:!B?:!51!?!A?JH?5J1!>H=@1!;<6!4?:C!
<3F16!B<H:36=1G!?G!O1!?JJ!;?B1!3F1!B<42J1R!BF?JJ1:>1G!<;!26<31B3=:>I!26<4<3=:>!?:@!
;HJ;=JJ=:>!3F1!6=>F3G!?:@!O1J;?61!<;!3F1!#P.G!?:@!3F1=6!;?4=J=1GN!oo!
!
$&"
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
The Center for Migrant Advocacy Philippines
takes full responsibility for the contents and analysis
of this publication.